Rate My Team

manlybeaver wrote:Anyone like to rate my team ?

smith parcell
graham woods lawrence critchon
parker surgess merrin rochow SST cartwright MCK
DCE hasting taylor rankin
hurrell avua henry scott
Gordon barba freeney gutherson french

Ad@m wrote:(Smith, Seggy)
(Woods, Graham, Lawerence) Welch
(Fensom, Surgess, Merrin, Paasi) Frei, Fitzgibbon
(Mullen, JRey, Hastings) Taylor
(Copley, Auva) Gutherson, Henry
(Mansour, MGordon, Feeney) Eden, CMatiutia

Ad@m wrote:(Smith, Seggy)
(Woods, Graham, Lawerence) Welch
(Fensom, Surgess, Merrin, Paasi) Frei, Fitzgibbon
(Mullen, JRey, Hastings) Taylor
(Copley, Auva) Gutherson, Henry
(Mansour, MGordon, Feeney) Eden, CMatiutia

Ad@m wrote:(Smith, Seggy)
(Woods, Graham, Lawerence) Welch
(Fensom, Surgess, Merrin, Paasi) Frei, Fitzgibbon
(Mullen, JRey, Hastings) Taylor
(Copley, Auva) Gutherson, Henry
(Mansour, MGordon, Feeney) Eden, CMatiutia

Krump wrote:
Very very light in the backs and I'm not sold on Mullen with Hodkinson there. That pack is nuts though.

Honeysett wrote:

Not picking DCE I feel is fantasy suicide. There is absolutely no reason that he will go backwards in scores. His kick metres should go up tenfold where as Mullen is an injury prone secondary half now. I would downgrade one of your monster forwards and upgrade to DCE.

Ad@m wrote:

I guess I could down grade one of the fwds to upgrade mullen to DCE or similar.  There are a few interesting mid rangers, but I was trying to get as many proven scorers in the FWDs.

I also think Maloney might be in for a good year this year. What you think?

Ad@m wrote:

I think Maloney is a solid pick but at the expensive of DCE? No. With Mullen, he's not going to be the dominant half at Newcastle. Hodkinson will take over a lot more of the kicking duties and Mullen will play more of a running game.
I guess I could down grade one of the fwds to upgrade mullen to DCE or similar.  There are a few interesting mid rangers, but I was trying to get as many proven scorers in the FWDs.

I also think Maloney might be in for a good year this year. What you think?

Goondalf wrote:Anyone car to rate this side?

Smith Lichaa
Surgess Stockwell Evans (Welch)
Merrin Graham Cartwright Whitehead (Pauli Henry)
DCE Hastings Rankin (Taylor)
Aubosson Auvaa (Scott MCK)
Mansour Gordon Feeney (Gutherson Eden)

Mighty Fishes wrote:Smith, Lichaa
Surgess, Stockwell, Lawrence, Pauli
Parker, Merrin, Rochow, Tuner, Carter, Frei
DCE, Hastings, Taylor, Martin
Crocker, Hurrell, Auv'a, Copely
Gutherson, Slater, Barba, Feeney, Scott

64k left over rip it apart

efil4iroam wrote:first timer, any help would be appreciated

Smith-Peats
Papalii-Graham-JTrob
Parker-Surgess-Cartwright
DCE-Hastings-Little john-Taylor
Hurrel-Lafai-BHenrY
BStuwart-Gordon-Gela mosby-French-Abbey

ForanAgainst wrote:Good morning. Have not posted a team in here since page 2, and it's changed quite a bit. I have two options I would like to get some opinions about. Appreciate any feedback.

Team Parcell
Smith(c), parcell
stockwell, grant, evans(r), lawerence
parker(vc), surgess, cartwright, aubbs(r), clawerence(r), 130k
dce, roberts, hastings(r), taylor
hurrell, copley, auva'a, 134k ctr/2rf
gordon, slater, mann, gutherson, feeney

Team Where Is Smith?
segeyaro, lichaa(r)
woods, stockwell(or grant), evans(r), 130k
parker(c), sst, cartwright(or ah mau), mcqueen(r), clawerence(r), 130k
dce, hastings, taylor, jniko
lafai, copley, auva'a, 134k ctr/2rf
ferguson, gordon, mann, gutherson, feeney

In both sides, I've tried to avoid much hyped players such as Rochow(took mcqueen cuz I'm a titans supporter :S), Passi, Sue, and the like. Copley is only there in case Auva'a doesn't make the team. two different approaches. What do you think?