Looping thread 2 - Electric Boogaloop

Camo123 wrote:

Cheers Snatch. I initially thought looking at that I could avoid both Dogs fuck it up scenario but forgot Piakura locks game 1

You can avoid both Bulldogs fuckup by going

Hughes Burbo Talagi Salmon

If both do well, swap Burbo and Strange (so Salmon is Piakura AE)
If Hughes does well only, swap Talagi and Galvin
If Salmon does well only, swap Burbo and strange and choose out of Talagi/Strange
If both do poorly, swap Talagi and Galvin

So this avoids both Dogs shitting the bed, but in one scenario you're taking a punt on Burbo over whatever Salmon puts up (but that relies on Hughes doing well which lets face it, is unlikely)

Appreciate any advice on this unruly mob:

Cook
May Murray Hughes
KPP Salmon
Fogarty Hutchison
Strange Kiraz
Teddy Papy Rapana

Lussick Gutho Flanagan Galvin
Chan Sitili Burbo Levi

Can I do something clever with Chan starting as an edge given he locks out first game?

Jele wrote:Appreciate any advice on this unruly mob:

Cook
May Murray Hughes
KPP Salmon
Fogarty Hutchison
Strange Kiraz
Teddy Papy Rapana

Lussick Gutho Flanagan Galvin
Chan Sitili Burbo Levi

Can I do something clever with Chan starting as an edge given he locks out first game?

Sitili is complicating things as an extra EDG that locks out at same time as Salmon but you can do Salmon and Burbo EDG loop. If you start Sitili over Hughes I think you can do same loop as mine above

Camo123 wrote:

Sitili is complicating things as an extra EDG that locks out at same time as Salmon but you can do Salmon and Burbo EDG loop. If you start Sitili over Hughes I think you can do same loop as mine above

Thanks Camo, so I set it up like this? Trying to get my head around whether this enables me a double loop or just a single (and if a single, can't I just do that with Galvin?).

Cook
May Murray Hughes
KPP Chan
Fogarty Hutchison
Strange Kiraz
Teddy Papy Rapana

Lussick Gutho Flanagan Galvin
Levi Salmon Burbo Sitili

Not sure I want to even consider Sitili coming off the bench over a starting Hughes. Of course, if there are late changes, then I can do the Sitili/Hughes swap you suggest (maybe like the loop @WT Winfield is doing this week).

Jele wrote:

Thanks Camo, so I set it up like this? Trying to get my head around whether this enables me a double loop or just a single (and if a single, can't I just do that with Galvin?).

Cook
May Murray Hughes
KPP Chan
Fogarty Hutchison
Strange Kiraz
Teddy Papy Rapana

Lussick Gutho Flanagan Galvin
Levi Salmon Burbo Sitili

Not sure I want to even consider Sitili coming off the bench over a starting Hughes. Of course, if there are late changes, then I can do the Sitili/Hughes swap you suggest (maybe like the loop @WT Winfield is doing this week).

You could also put Salmon over Hughes (my bad I missed this) and use that double loop above. I think I’d rather be looping Hughes over Salmon anyway as the non Max King prop has only lasted 20, 28, 14 mins (other game injury affected)

I’ve tried permutations and don’t think you can maximise outcomes with 3 EDGs in EMG with no DPP starters

So I'm not normally a looper, but Hughes score is good.

Camo told me I could switch Galvin with Levi, and I will get Hughes score instead of Levi, is this correct? I hadn't posted my entire team before.

Is it that simple? Or am I missing something? Thanks heaps

Yes just swap Galvin and Levi

Camo123 wrote:Yes just swap Galvin and Levi

Alrighty, thanks Camo

Finch wrote:

Alrighty, thanks Camo

Or Finefuiaki/whoever you think scores lowest

Camo123 wrote:

Or Finefuiaki/whoever you think scores lowest

Fine has more potential, so will leave him in there compared to Levi

Thanks mate

Cheese
May, Shoes, Salmon
Crichton, KPP
Hynes, Flanagan
Kris, Strange
Ponga, Papenhuyzen, JC

Harris, McInnes, Curran, Levi
Kiraz, Burbo, Chan, Galvin

I don’t really have a viable loopy option here, do I? Just pick and stick?

If HTF dpp were positioned in the starting 13 at WFB, and laurie & talagi were in 18 - 21, you'd get Laurie's score right ?

Khany wrote:If HTF dpp were positioned in the starting 13 at WFB, and laurie & talagi were in 18 - 21, you'd get Laurie's score right ?

I'm sort of questioning why you'd have Laurie.

But yes, if HTF is starting WFB, only a WFB can replace him

Thanks, he's just an example, I'd probably have Chevy there in practice

Anyone got any thoughts on improving this loop

I think Lussick/Cheese are 2 I'm more likely to want to loop out.

If I want Lussick + Cheese I do nothing

If I want Cheese but not Lussick I sawp Kris with Shoes, and Kris will score

If I want Lussick but not Cheese, I swap KPP with Smithies and kris will score

If I want neither Cheese nor Lussick I swap KPP with Smithies and Kris with Shows, then Levi and Chevy will score (This means scoring Chevy so would probably need 2 total garbage scores to invoke this)
All players needing to be swapped don't lockout until Sunday, so can see Lussick and Cheese play before deciding.

Milchcow wrote:

Anyone got any thoughts on improving this loop

I think Lussick/Cheese are 2 I'm more likely to want to loop out.

If I want Lussick + Cheese I do nothing

If I want Cheese but not Lussick I sawp Kris with Shoes, and Kris will score

If I want Lussick but not Cheese, I swap KPP with Smithies and kris will score

If I want neither Cheese nor Lussick I swap KPP with Smithies and Kris with Shows, then Levi and Chevy will score (This means scoring Chevy so would probably need 2 total garbage scores to invoke this)
All players needing to be swapped don't lockout until Sunday, so can see Lussick and Cheese play before deciding.

Just on the last part of this loop; after you swap KPP with Smithies you then need to swap Smithies with Chevy so that you can avoid Lussick's score. I guess you were already planning on doing this but it wasn't clear from all the talk about Chevrolets and Levies

Wanting to try and make the most out of my three mid EMG's for Smithies.

Brailey
Cotter - Tohu - Smithies
KPP - Angus
Dbro - Hynes
Iro - Garrick
Faalago - Atkison - Armstrong

Bateman - blore - galvin - Kris
Shoes - Salmon - Cheese - Piakura

Thinking is Shoes and salmon score well, they both stay where they are, but if salmon scores poorly then i swap cheese with Kris.

I don't get a look at Piakura this way, just wondering if there's a smarter option for me?

Thanks

Welsh Mafia wrote:Wanting to try and make the most out of my three mid EMG's for Smithies.

Brailey
Cotter - Tohu - Smithies
KPP - Angus
Dbro - Hynes
Iro - Garrick
Faalago - Atkison - Armstrong

Bateman - blore - galvin - Kris
Shoes - Salmon - Cheese - Piakura

Thinking is Shoes and salmon score well, they both stay where they are, but if salmon scores poorly then i swap cheese with Kris.

If Shoes scores crap as well, you can swap Cheese with Smithies and Piakura with Kris. They had both want to score pretty bad to risk taking Piakura's score though

Welsh Mafia wrote:
I don't get a look at Piakura this way, just wondering if there's a smarter option for me?

Thanks

If Shoes and Salmon weren't from the same team there may have been some nice options. I guess all the EDG's and MID's are a bit inconvenient for looping as well

Cookie Monster wrote:



If Shoes scores crap as well, you can swap Cheese with Smithies and Piakura with Kris. They had both want to score pretty bad to risk taking Piakura's score though






If Shoes and Salmon weren't from the same team there may have been some nice options. I guess all the EDG's and MID's are a bit inconvenient for looping as well

Thanks for your time as ever mate Appreciated.

Hey team!

With Tohu out, I now have him and Salmon on the pine and wondering If i could loop?

Brailey
Cotter - Jolliffe - Smithies
KPP - angus
Hynes - Dbro
Garrick - Iro
Atkinson - Armstrong - Weekes

Blore - Galvin - Tohu - Salmon
Piakura - Cheese - Kris - Shoes

Would love to see if I can get some options with the EMG's?