HomeSorry didn't think that through properly. If a player doesn't play they will get 0 in this challenge. If you want to take that route you can.Chewie wrote:
So a player sitting on the interchange scoring 0 is allowed in our teams. They will score 0 points. Is that right?
But the 18th man is not valid?
NRLFF Survivor Season 2
FalconSloth- Posts : 2433
Reputation : 1351
Join date : 2019-02-27
Location : Brisbane
Regulator- Posts : 2514
Reputation : 1522
Join date : 2016-03-01
FalconSloth wrote:
Sorry didn't think that through properly. If a player doesn't play they will get 0 in this challenge. If you want to take that route you can.
So player averages 20.
Let's say they are 19th man. They don't make the final 17. So they don't play.
The score will be 0 for that player correct? not 20 minus 0.
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
[quote="Regulator"]
So player averages 20.
Let's say they are 19th man. They don't make the final 17. So they don't play.
The score will be 0 for that player correct? not 20 minus 0. [/quote
Yeah sounds like you get 0 straight up for that player if they don't take the field. Otherwise it would be selecting players in the 18+ with the highest averages
FalconSloth wrote:
Sorry didn't think that through properly. If a player doesn't play they will get 0 in this challenge. If you want to take that route you can.
So player averages 20.
Let's say they are 19th man. They don't make the final 17. So they don't play.
The score will be 0 for that player correct? not 20 minus 0. [/quote
Yeah sounds like you get 0 straight up for that player if they don't take the field. Otherwise it would be selecting players in the 18+ with the highest averages
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
FalconSloth wrote:
Sorry didn't think that through properly. If a player doesn't play they will get 0 in this challenge. If you want to take that route you can.
Does the 18th man trigger the Reserve player for that position if they don't take the field if you have him listed in your team?
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
The Cheese tribe just hit page 51 
Regulator- Posts : 2514
Reputation : 1522
Join date : 2016-03-01
My message to sloth stuck in outbox not sent box?
Moanaman- Posts : 3296
Reputation : 2940
Join date : 2020-01-27
Location : Up the Wahs!
Just means he has not read it yet
FalconSloth- Posts : 2433
Reputation : 1351
Join date : 2019-02-27
Location : Brisbane
Cheese
Rabbits21
Koroisau (L. Croker)
M. Croker Leniu Bullemor (Naeme)
Wilton Butcher (CHN)
Salmon Biondi Odo (Amone)
HTF Kris (Penisini)
Jaxson Paulo T. Martin Mathew Feagai (D. Young)
RandomSil
C. Paix (B. Smith)
G. Burgess, C. Harawira-Naera, J. Aloiai (S. Sorensen)
N. Butcher, K. Palasia (N. Brown)
B. Biondi-Odo, M. Moses (J. Salmon)
S. Kris, Z. Lomax (M. Taulagi)
Mat. Feagai, Jax Paulo, B. Simonsson (E. Lee)
Cunbert
Koro (croker)
Croker Leniu Bullemor (Max king)
Wilton N.Butcher (CHN)
Salmon T.Martin (Wishart)
Hammer Mbye (Penisini)
Feagai Paulo Rusell (ikuvalu)
Jumping Marlin
Koro (Paix)
SST, M Croker, Leniu (Bullermor)
CHN, Butcher (Wilton)
Biondi-Odo, TMM (Schneider)
Kris, M Feaigai (Avo)
HTF, Jackson Paulo, D Young (Asi)
Moanaman
Koroisau (LCroker)
Utoikamanu MCroker NBrown (Palasia)
Bullemor Butcher (Wilton)
Amone TMM (Moses)
Feagai Kris (Tass)
Young Paulo Walsh (Edwards)
Chewie
Paix (Koroisau)
Leniu, Taukeiaho, MCroker (Bullemor)
Butcher, Aitken (Wilton)
DBrown, Averillo (Wishart)
JPaulo, Kris (Tabuai-Fidow)
Walsh, Mathew Feagai, Russell (Gutherson)
Pookus McFly
Cook (Koro)
Croker Utoikamanu Leniu (Bullemor)
Wilton Butcher (CHN)
Drinkwater Schneider (Wishart)
Feagai Mbye (Penisini)
Young Russell Paulo (ikuvalu)
Regulator
Paix (Brandon Smith)
Nathan Butcher, Mat Croker, SST (Bullemor)
Aitken, Wilton (Baker)
Biondi-Odo, Te Maire Martin(Salmon)
Kris, Averillo (Penisini)
Jaxson Paulo, Dom Young, Sean Russell (Mat Feagai)
Carty Party
Wolfking
Koro (Croker)
Leniu Williams JJackson (Makatoa)
Fitzgibbon CHN (Tago)
TMM Brown (Moses)
Kris Feagai (Bird)
HTF Paulo Hoy (Walsh)
Teetheater
Apisai Koroisau (Blayke Brailey)
Mat Croker / Jack Williams / Oregan Kafusi (Spencer Leniu)
Lachlan Fitzgibbon / Corey Harawira-Naera (Talakai)
Mitchell Moses / Corey Paix (Bird)
Sebastian Kris / Mathew Feagai (Tago)
Jaxson Paulo / Clint Gutherson / Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow (Stephen Crichton)
B/L
Randall (Cook)
Cotter Klemmer Rudolf (AFB)
Papalili CHN
Hynes Moses (Hunt)
Penis Suli (Tass)
Coates Ravalawa D Young (Marzhew)
Easytiger
Blayke Brailey (Koroisau)
Jing JJackson Leniu (Tamou)
Talakai CHN (Fitzgibbon)
Moses Brooks (Paix)
Kris Suli ( Mat Feagai)
Paulo Mulitalo Drinkwater (TMM)
Welshy
HOK Apisai Koroisau
MID Mat Croker
MID Jack Williams
MID Oregon Kaufusi
EDG Lachlan Fitzgibbon
EDG Corey Harawira-Naera
HLF Dylan Brown
HLF Corey Paix
CTR Sebastian Kris
CTR Mathew Feagai
WFB Jaxson Paulo
WFB Gutho
WFB Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow
Reserves
HOK Blayke Brailey
MID Spencer Leniu
EDG Siosifa Talakai
HLF Te Maire Martin
CTR Izack Tago
WFB Stephen Crichton
Studogg101
Apisai Koroisau (Lachlan Croker)
Spencer Leniu, Josh Jackson, Jack Williams (Makesi Makatoa)
Siosifa Talakai, Corey Harawira-Naera (Izack Tago)
Mitchell Moses, Te Maire Martin (Dylan Brown)
Sebastian Kris, Mathew Feagai (Moses Suli)
Hamiso Tabuai-Fido, Jaxson Paulo, Tex Hoy (Reece Walsh)
Papadontbleach
Korisau (Brailey)
Leniu, M.Croker, Kaufusi (J.Williams)
CHN, Fitzgibbon (Talakai)
Schneider, D.Brown (Paix)
Kris, Feagai (Suli)
S.Crichton, HTF, Drinkwater (TM Martin)
Rabbits21
Koroisau (L. Croker)
M. Croker Leniu Bullemor (Naeme)
Wilton Butcher (CHN)
Salmon Biondi Odo (Amone)
HTF Kris (Penisini)
Jaxson Paulo T. Martin Mathew Feagai (D. Young)
RandomSil
C. Paix (B. Smith)
G. Burgess, C. Harawira-Naera, J. Aloiai (S. Sorensen)
N. Butcher, K. Palasia (N. Brown)
B. Biondi-Odo, M. Moses (J. Salmon)
S. Kris, Z. Lomax (M. Taulagi)
Mat. Feagai, Jax Paulo, B. Simonsson (E. Lee)
Cunbert
Koro (croker)
Croker Leniu Bullemor (Max king)
Wilton N.Butcher (CHN)
Salmon T.Martin (Wishart)
Hammer Mbye (Penisini)
Feagai Paulo Rusell (ikuvalu)
Jumping Marlin
Koro (Paix)
SST, M Croker, Leniu (Bullermor)
CHN, Butcher (Wilton)
Biondi-Odo, TMM (Schneider)
Kris, M Feaigai (Avo)
HTF, Jackson Paulo, D Young (Asi)
Moanaman
Koroisau (LCroker)
Utoikamanu MCroker NBrown (Palasia)
Bullemor Butcher (Wilton)
Amone TMM (Moses)
Feagai Kris (Tass)
Young Paulo Walsh (Edwards)
Chewie
Paix (Koroisau)
Leniu, Taukeiaho, MCroker (Bullemor)
Butcher, Aitken (Wilton)
DBrown, Averillo (Wishart)
JPaulo, Kris (Tabuai-Fidow)
Walsh, Mathew Feagai, Russell (Gutherson)
Pookus McFly
Cook (Koro)
Croker Utoikamanu Leniu (Bullemor)
Wilton Butcher (CHN)
Drinkwater Schneider (Wishart)
Feagai Mbye (Penisini)
Young Russell Paulo (ikuvalu)
Regulator
Paix (Brandon Smith)
Nathan Butcher, Mat Croker, SST (Bullemor)
Aitken, Wilton (Baker)
Biondi-Odo, Te Maire Martin(Salmon)
Kris, Averillo (Penisini)
Jaxson Paulo, Dom Young, Sean Russell (Mat Feagai)
Carty Party
Wolfking
Koro (Croker)
Leniu Williams JJackson (Makatoa)
Fitzgibbon CHN (Tago)
TMM Brown (Moses)
Kris Feagai (Bird)
HTF Paulo Hoy (Walsh)
Teetheater
Apisai Koroisau (Blayke Brailey)
Mat Croker / Jack Williams / Oregan Kafusi (Spencer Leniu)
Lachlan Fitzgibbon / Corey Harawira-Naera (Talakai)
Mitchell Moses / Corey Paix (Bird)
Sebastian Kris / Mathew Feagai (Tago)
Jaxson Paulo / Clint Gutherson / Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow (Stephen Crichton)
B/L
Randall (Cook)
Cotter Klemmer Rudolf (AFB)
Papalili CHN
Hynes Moses (Hunt)
Penis Suli (Tass)
Coates Ravalawa D Young (Marzhew)
Easytiger
Blayke Brailey (Koroisau)
Jing JJackson Leniu (Tamou)
Talakai CHN (Fitzgibbon)
Moses Brooks (Paix)
Kris Suli ( Mat Feagai)
Paulo Mulitalo Drinkwater (TMM)
Welshy
HOK Apisai Koroisau
MID Mat Croker
MID Jack Williams
MID Oregon Kaufusi
EDG Lachlan Fitzgibbon
EDG Corey Harawira-Naera
HLF Dylan Brown
HLF Corey Paix
CTR Sebastian Kris
CTR Mathew Feagai
WFB Jaxson Paulo
WFB Gutho
WFB Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow
Reserves
HOK Blayke Brailey
MID Spencer Leniu
EDG Siosifa Talakai
HLF Te Maire Martin
CTR Izack Tago
WFB Stephen Crichton
Studogg101
Apisai Koroisau (Lachlan Croker)
Spencer Leniu, Josh Jackson, Jack Williams (Makesi Makatoa)
Siosifa Talakai, Corey Harawira-Naera (Izack Tago)
Mitchell Moses, Te Maire Martin (Dylan Brown)
Sebastian Kris, Mathew Feagai (Moses Suli)
Hamiso Tabuai-Fido, Jaxson Paulo, Tex Hoy (Reece Walsh)
Papadontbleach
Korisau (Brailey)
Leniu, M.Croker, Kaufusi (J.Williams)
CHN, Fitzgibbon (Talakai)
Schneider, D.Brown (Paix)
Kris, Feagai (Suli)
S.Crichton, HTF, Drinkwater (TM Martin)
Moanaman- Posts : 3296
Reputation : 2940
Join date : 2020-01-27
Location : Up the Wahs!
No Milchcow entry?
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
This was my team
HOK Apisai Koroisau
MID Mat Croker
MID Jack Williams
MID Isaiah Papalii
EDG Siosifa Talakai
EDG Corey Harawira-Naera
HLF Mitchell Moses
HLF Cory Paix
CTR Sebastian Kris
CTR Daejarn Asi
WFB Jaxson Paulo
WFB Ronaldo Mulitalo
WFB Mathew Feagai
res
HOK Blayke Brailey
MID Oregon Kaufusi
EDG Lachlan Fitzgibbon
HLF Te Maire Martin
CTR Izack Tago
WFB Tex Hoy
FalconSloth- Posts : 2433
Reputation : 1351
Join date : 2019-02-27
Location : Brisbane
I definitely went into his message and copied his team. I must have just blanked out and not pasted it
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
Where is Chucky's team?
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
This is how I understand the rules for this challenge:
Jaxon Paulo would have scored 0 points for this challenge?
And Brenko Lee would be an non player as 18th man and will trigger the Reserve for that position if he was in your submitted team?
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
Chewie wrote:
This is how I understand the rules for this challenge:
Jaxon Paulo would have scored 0 points for this challenge?
And Brenko Lee would be an non player as 18th man and will trigger the Reserve for that position if he was in your submitted team?
Why wouldn't Paulo and Lee both trigger reserve? (otherwise why did we name reserves if not to cover players who didn't play)
Chucky- Posts : 3180
Reputation : 3402
Join date : 2015-10-01
Age : 55
Location : Port Stephens
Chewie wrote:Where is Chucky's team?
Moanaman- Posts : 3296
Reputation : 2940
Join date : 2020-01-27
Location : Up the Wahs!
My take is this...
Paulo did play, he gets a cap for that game as he was named on the bench, he just wasn't used and did not take the field. That's +31
Lee is 18th man, he didn't play, that's reserve
@falconsloth to the yellow courtesy phone
Paulo did play, he gets a cap for that game as he was named on the bench, he just wasn't used and did not take the field. That's +31
Lee is 18th man, he didn't play, that's reserve
@falconsloth to the yellow courtesy phone
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
We need some clarity on the rules Falcon otherwise a civil war will break out on the Island
Chewie- Fanatic
- Posts : 18002
Reputation : 12753
Join date : 2016-02-02
Location : Milenium Falcon
easytiger- Moderator
- NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2022
Posts : 4602
Reputation : 5731
Join date : 2020-01-27
Location : The Kingdom of the Lord of the Byes
Moanaman wrote:My take is this...
Paulo did play, he gets a cap for that game as he was named on the bench, he just wasn't used and did not take the field. That's +31
Lee is 18th man, he didn't play, that's reserve
@falconsloth to the yellow courtesy phone
Moanaman- Posts : 3296
Reputation : 2940
Join date : 2020-01-27
Location : Up the Wahs!
