NRLFF Survivor Season 2 - Part 2

With some captains ruled out and the potential for more the fairest way was to remove captains. If a rule that would shift the captaincy onto someone else was imposed it would make it unfair as you may have not picked the same captain if you knew what would happen if they were ruled out.

Everyone’s been put on an even playing field this way.

cool, cool, cool, cool, cool.... as long as my vice captain still counts

FalconSloth wrote:With some captains ruled out and the potential for more the fairest way was to remove captains. If a rule that would shift the captaincy onto someone else was imposed it would make it unfair as you may have not picked the same captain if you knew what would happen if they were ruled out.

Everyone’s been put on an even playing field this way.

Since you haven't said otherwise or revealed any results, I'm carrying on like I'm still in this....

Milchcow
Ryan Papenhuyzen 28
2. Sione Katoa 25
3. Jesse Ramien 76
4. Justin Olam 22
5. Ronaldo Mulitalo 40
6. Matt Moylan 43
9. Blayke Brailey 66
10. Nelson Asofa Solomona 41
11. Briton Nikora 37
12. Wade Graham 14
13. Josh King 31
14. Aiden Tolman 42
15. Cameron Mcinnes 53
16. Teig WIlton 22
540

Cunbert
papy 28
2 - katoa 25
3 - ramien 76
4 - Tracey 37
5 - mulitalo 40
6 - meaney 38
9 - brailey 66
10 - nelson 41
11 - nikora 37
12 - Bromwich 32
13 - king 31
14 - tolman 42
15 - mccinnes 53
16 - Wilton 22
567

StuDogg101
Papenhuyzen 28
2. Katoa 25
3. Ramien 76
4. Olam 22
5. Mulitalo 40
6. Meaney 38
9. Smith 61
10. Asofa-Solomona 41
11. Nikora 37
12. Graham 14
13. Finucane 44
14. Tolman 42
15. McInnes 53
16. Wilton 22
543

Jumping Marlin

Papy 28
Katoa 25
Ramien 76
Tracey 37
Mulitalo 40
Moylan 43
Brailey 66
NAS 41
Nikora 37
KBrom 32
King 31
Tolman 42
McInnes 53
Wilton 22
573

EasyTiger
Paps 28
Katoa 25
Ramien 76
Tracey 37
Muli 40
Meaney 38
Smith 61
NAS 41
Nikora 37
KBrom 32
Finucane 44
Tolman 42
McInnes 53
Wilton 22
576

Chewie
Papenhuyzen 28
Katoa 25
Ramien 76
Tracey 37
Mulitalo 40
Meaney 38
Brailey 66
Asofa-Solomona 41
Nikora 37
K Bromwich 32
J King 31
Tolman 42
McInnes 53
Wilton 22
568

Wolfking

1. Pappy 28
2. Katoa 25
3. Seve 34
4. Olam 22
5. Mulitalo 40
6. Meaney 38
9. Smith 61
10. NAS 41
11. Nikora 37
12. Graham 14
13. King 31
14. Tolman 42
15. McInnes 53
16. Wilton 22
488

RandomSil
Papenhyuzen 28
2. Ieremia 22
3. Seve 34
4. Olam 22
5. Anderson 9
6. Meaney 38
9. Smith 61
10. Asofa-Solomona 41
11. Lewis 45
12. Bromwich 32
13. King 31
14. Wishart 16
15. Kamikamica 35
16. MacDonald 43
457

Rabbits21
Papenhuzyen 28
Katoa 25
Ramien 76
Olam 22
Mulitalo 40
Meaney 38
Brailey 66
NAS 41
Nikora 37
W. Graham 14
J. King 31
Tolman 42
McInnes 53
Wilton 22
535

B/L
papy 28
katoa 25
ramien 76
olam 22
mulitalo 40
meaney 38
brailey 66
nikora 37
bromwich 32
finucane 44
Tolman 42
mcinnes 53
wilton 22
525

Papadontbleach

1 Papy 28
2Ieremia 22
3 Ramien 76
4 Tracey 37
5 Anderson 9
6 Meaney 38
9 Brailey 66
10 NAS 41
11 Lewis 45
12 Graham 14
13 JKing 31
14 Wishart 16
15 McInnes 53
16 Wilton 22
498

Teeth Eater
1 Pappy 28
2 Katoa 25
3 Ramien 76
4 Olam 22
5 Mulitalo 40
6 Meaney 38
9 Brailey 66
10 NAS 41
11 Nikora 37
12 K.Bromwich 32
13 Finucane 44
14 Tolman 42
15 McInnes 53
16 Teig Wilton 22
566

So if no Captains are ruled out in the last two games doesn't it make sense to allow Captains to still be in play?

I understand the reasoning for the first couple, but seems a shame to scratch a key point of difference for teams going forwards if it proves unnecessary - just a thought

Wolfking, Random and Papadontbleach are knocked out after the first round.

easytiger wrote:So if no Captains are ruled out in the last two games doesn't it make sense to allow Captains to still be in play?

I understand the reasoning for the first couple, but seems a shame to scratch a key point of difference for teams going forwards if it proves unnecessary - just a thought

Good point. If any remaining player has their captain ruled out, there will be no captains for that game. Otherwise captains will still count. This is for every game. I think this is the fairest way to handle this.

I picked my captains, in part, by trying to work out what positions were safe from late changes. I'd like to see them count

So I just realised I have both #4’s in this game. I’ll see myself out don’t think there is enough variance in this challenge to be 1 man down

wow tonight's game was a nail biter
It came down to 3 player positions

sivo (48) vs nofo (49)
penis (15) vs doueihi (15)
mahoney (48) vs nbrown 41)

updates to determine who will make it through

The 2 last minute nofo tries really changed things quickly

I've got ET winning by 4 points
A tie between Cunbert, Teeth, and myself in 2nd place.
JM 3rd, and Milch 4th.

numbers 5, 8, 10, 13-17 all scrapped


So ET goes through to the final game, and everyone else gets eliminated???

Chewie wrote:I've got ET winning by 4 points
A tie between Cunbert, Teeth, and myself in 2nd place.
JM 3rd, and Milch 4th.

numbers 5, 8, 10, 13-17 all scrapped


So ET goes through to the final game, and everyone else gets eliminated???

Sounds good, lock it in Eddie, I mean Chewie

I'm sure FS will confirm, but would imagine Chewie, Teeth & Cunbert all go through for the final.

Should be a good match and anyones (Immunity) game

Chewie wrote:I've got ET winning by 4 points
A tie between Cunbert, Teeth, and myself in 2nd place.
JM 3rd, and Milch 4th.

numbers 5, 8, 10, 13-17 all scrapped


So ET goes through to the final game, and everyone else gets eliminated???

Any reason 15,16 are scrapped?

I’ve got it with numbers 5,8,13,14,17 scrapped
ET 531
Milch 525
Cunbert 523 (no number 3)
Teeth 522 (no number 3)
JM 518
Chewie 515 (opacic really hurt you)

And I’ve no idea what happened to centre’s. Even the guys that named both Parra centres have them in the wrong order 4 for penis 3 for blake. Did penis and blake change numbers mid week??

Here's original teams with
3. Blake, 4 Penisini

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/nrl-2022-round-17-teams-ins-and-outs-injuries-te-maire-martin-broncos-jayden-brailey-bradman-best-knights-nicho-hynes-sharks/news-story/71aea83b2b1df19bc0780d13fc6cb422

They ran out the other way around though.

And 15+16 should still be live - they were named as interchange and played as interchange

It all depends on how you interpret the rules
... whatever FalconSloth says goes