HomeBreak the tie, who do we trade in
Last edited by Milchcow on Thu May 19, 2022 11:42 am; edited 1 time in total
R11 Trade ins
Poll
who do we get
- [ 14 ]
[45%]
- [ 3 ]
- [10%]
- [ 2 ]
- [6%]
- [ 12 ]
- [39%]
Total Votes: 31
Poll closed
Poll closed
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25408
Reputation : 17834
Join date : 2015-07-31
Last edited by Milchcow on Thu May 19, 2022 11:42 am; edited 1 time in total
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13130
Reputation : 9661
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
Thoughts I just wrote in the previous vote thread:
I think Robson and MCInnes are potential keepers, with Robson having the advantage of playing the first bye and slightly more certainty about his scoring
Butcher is a bye rounds play, will need a future trade. Pretty sideways from Randall. Would see him as the 2nd player in this trades decision.
Peoples is an enabler, I’m not even convinced he’s a cow. I would only get him if getting Robson
So for me it’s either Robson/People or McInnes/Butcher. Don’t rate the other combos. I like the Robson one most
I think Robson and MCInnes are potential keepers, with Robson having the advantage of playing the first bye and slightly more certainty about his scoring
Butcher is a bye rounds play, will need a future trade. Pretty sideways from Randall. Would see him as the 2nd player in this trades decision.
Peoples is an enabler, I’m not even convinced he’s a cow. I would only get him if getting Robson
So for me it’s either Robson/People or McInnes/Butcher. Don’t rate the other combos. I like the Robson one most
Guest- Guest
One thing for me if you are trying to split McInnes and Robson.
Purely on timing McInnes should still be in reach for round 14 and could be a good swap with Mking or even Taumalolo
Robson could also be a potential captain for the bye too
Purely on timing McInnes should still be in reach for round 14 and could be a good swap with Mking or even Taumalolo
Robson could also be a potential captain for the bye too
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13130
Reputation : 9661
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
^^ Agree with this - Robson more urgent if you want both, and a legit r13 Captain option
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25408
Reputation : 17834
Join date : 2015-07-31
Personally I am not massively big on Robson
Currently in a bit of form, but not massively underpriced compared to his long term average.
Would rather wait and go to Cook/Grant as prime hooker.
That said he's still a decent scorer and not going to be too concerned if he comes in. I guess there is some concern about McInnes's long term role as well.
Currently in a bit of form, but not massively underpriced compared to his long term average.
Would rather wait and go to Cook/Grant as prime hooker.
That said he's still a decent scorer and not going to be too concerned if he comes in. I guess there is some concern about McInnes's long term role as well.
Guest- Guest
Milchcow wrote:Personally I am not massively big on Robson
Currently in a bit of form, but not massively underpriced compared to his long term average.
Would rather wait and go to Cook/Grant as prime hooker.
That said he's still a decent scorer and not going to be too concerned if he comes in. I guess there is some concern about McInnes's long term role as well.
The issue is the team has a few holes, if there was a bunch of reliable cows kicking the door down then I would agree to get the higher priced guns
I agree he is in a rich vein of form and that is partially down to his 80min games
Not without risk and the bye points will be handy too.
Regardless can’t really blame it being popular given his scoring for his price and only being a small jump up in price from trade outs
Jack Torrance- Posts : 810
Reputation : 647
Join date : 2021-02-23
Location : Hopefully ahead of mtvb ;)
I've voted Robson
I'm bringing him in so thought its suitable to vote for what I'm doing myself
I rate him as a r13 captain option warm body anyway
I'm bringing him in so thought its suitable to vote for what I'm doing myself
I rate him as a r13 captain option warm body anyway