HomeRethinking my trades, Safiti/Carter out for Mannering/NPR - good idea?
2016 NRL.com Fantasy thread part 23
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8950
Reputation : 6471
Join date : 2015-09-28
Finch- Posts : 9577
Reputation : 2801
Join date : 2016-03-02
Henry has named an unchanged side for the Dragons clash but five-eighth Tyrone Roberts (knee) is expected to train on Wednesday after Cameron Cullen debuted in his place against the Sharks.
“Tyrone’s not really in the mix at the moment,” Henry said.
“He hasn’t run yet. He’ll know when he’s right to go.
“Structurally his knee’s OK but it takes time to heal and feel better.
“He’ll show us how he jumps around at training.
“Tyrone’s not really in the mix at the moment,” Henry said.
“He hasn’t run yet. He’ll know when he’s right to go.
“Structurally his knee’s OK but it takes time to heal and feel better.
“He’ll show us how he jumps around at training.
Finch- Posts : 9577
Reputation : 2801
Join date : 2016-03-02
So it sounds like Roberts wont be playing this week, and maybe not next week.
Titans play Saturday next week. It could be worth the punt, maybe.
(Do you guys see what I did there? "Punt" because he is a half and he kicks the ball.... Yeah....)
Titans play Saturday next week. It could be worth the punt, maybe.
(Do you guys see what I did there? "Punt" because he is a half and he kicks the ball.... Yeah....)
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19768
Reputation : 10004
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
my tv broke wrote:will joel edwards be used in the middle of the field? 40k more expensive than a cheap cash out.. pretty hard to tell how many mins he will get and what sort of security he has :/
edit i suppose aloiai is the same price and probably further up the pecking order anyway. eh.
Edwards weened back in from injury through NSW Cup. Not 100% sure Aloiai was ahead of Edwards before he got injured.
But yes, looking at that bench, which is pretty much all backrowers (slightly better than all hookers) Edwards would be playing up front. Gut feel is Buchanan comes into the 17 though. Not saying for Edwards, but just think there is a fair chance he plays.
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8950
Reputation : 6471
Join date : 2015-09-28
Finch wrote:So it sounds like Roberts wont be playing this week, and maybe not next week.
Titans play Saturday next week. It could be worth the punt, maybe.
(Do you guys see what I did there? "Punt" because he is a half and he kicks the ball.... Yeah....)
That's a paddlin
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19768
Reputation : 10004
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
Honeysett wrote:Rethinking my trades, Safiti/Carter out for Mannering/NPR - good idea?
No dramas doing the Mannering trade this week, but going on averages he should be another 10k cheaper next week at least. Safiti could still make that this week as well, so could be a 20k swing against you. In saying that, you get the extra points. By NPR, do you mean you are going to kill offa spot with a complete nuffie, or looking for a potential bye cover rookie?
Spectre- Posts : 3196
Reputation : 530
Join date : 2015-12-14
Mannering or Fensom?
Guest- Guest
Go Merrin instead.jstands wrote:Mannering or Fensom?
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8950
Reputation : 6471
Join date : 2015-09-28
SI wrote:
No dramas doing the Mannering trade this week, but going on averages he should be another 10k cheaper next week at least. Safiti could still make that this week as well, so could be a 20k swing against you. In saying that, you get the extra points. By NPR, do you mean you are going to kill offa spot with a complete nuffie, or looking for a potential bye cover rookie?
Carter could lose that extra money though so I think I'll be no better off? What do you reckon?
I need someone for under 175K. Any suggestions?
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19768
Reputation : 10004
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
jstands wrote:Mannering or Fensom?
Mannering to me. Fensom plays the round of death, but can see Mannering outscoring him by 100 or more in total come round 26, all things being equal.
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28424
Reputation : 21079
Join date : 2016-01-08
SI wrote:
Edwards weened back in from injury through NSW Cup. Not 100% sure Aloiai was ahead of Edwards before he got injured.
But yes, looking at that bench, which is pretty much all backrowers (slightly better than all hookers) Edwards would be playing up front. Gut feel is Buchanan comes into the 17 though. Not saying for Edwards, but just think there is a fair chance he plays.
he may just be worth a punt.. returned in rnd 2 but got injured. played in rnd 4, 60 mins off the bench. started prop in rnd 5 and then lock in rnd 6.
Sik- Posts : 898
Reputation : 135
Join date : 2016-02-01
Age : 40
Location : Brisbane
Showbags wrote:
Same dilemma....but who do you cash the buggers out to? I have actually been contemplating matai (crazy as it sounds) but even if he scores 25s he only nets me 70k, not worth it.
Anyone got any ideas? preferably a FRF, Ideal move is trade out Carter to a cheapy CC, move JTrbo to 2RF for depth in that position. Means next week when I turf JSaifiti will have forwards.
Graham, Surgess, BLaw
Fensom, Mannering, Merrin, JTrbo, Whitehead
Thoughts on DSaifiti?
3688 24 trades in bank (23 after this week)
I was thinking Asiata. He plays 2 byes. He's cheap @$128k
Guest- Guest
Find a few K and go Hampton.Honeysett wrote:
Carter could lose that extra money though so I think I'll be no better off? What do you reckon?
I need someone for under 175K. Any suggestions?
Showbags- Posts : 1217
Reputation : 150
Join date : 2016-01-29
filthridden wrote:
That's the million dollar question and why I'm waiting a week in the hope that a good option will pop up. Unlikely and might have to take a big punt on someone who's not that cheap or someone I hope will get some game time soon.
Yeah my only concern is if i dont dump carter this week and he gets 20, loses 10-15k. Mannering with a high tackle count against dogs can easily hit his BE and not drop money. As i will be upgrading jsaifit to mannering, if i turf carter next week after he loses money that has me at about 200k in bank. will be very tight if mannering goes big or something happens to jsaifiti and he goes below BE....
Damnit all, doing my head in lol.
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19768
Reputation : 10004
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
Honeysett wrote:SI wrote:
No dramas doing the Mannering trade this week, but going on averages he should be another 10k cheaper next week at least. Safiti could still make that this week as well, so could be a 20k swing against you. In saying that, you get the extra points. By NPR, do you mean you are going to kill offa spot with a complete nuffie, or looking for a potential bye cover rookie?
Carter could lose that extra money though so I think I'll be no better off? What do you reckon?
I need someone for under 175K. Any suggestions?
Ahh, sorry. So you need Carter traded out as well to get Mannering? My bad, was looking at the Jaifiti to Mannering in isolation. Fair call. Anyone got Carter's BE? I assume he spells McInnes for 20 this week? Although Clark can play hooker as well.
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19768
Reputation : 10004
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
my tv broke wrote:SI wrote:
Edwards weened back in from injury through NSW Cup. Not 100% sure Aloiai was ahead of Edwards before he got injured.
But yes, looking at that bench, which is pretty much all backrowers (slightly better than all hookers) Edwards would be playing up front. Gut feel is Buchanan comes into the 17 though. Not saying for Edwards, but just think there is a fair chance he plays.
he may just be worth a punt.. returned in rnd 2 but got injured. played in rnd 4, 60 mins off the bench. started prop in rnd 5 and then lock in rnd 6.
Are they Edwards' NSW Cup minutes? If so, where did you get them?
Showbags- Posts : 1217
Reputation : 150
Join date : 2016-01-29
Sik wrote:
I was thinking Asiata. He plays 2 byes. He's cheap @$128k
Considered it, but horrible scoring. Is he really likely to s ore more than 20 during byes? Is a trade worth 40-60pts and a bad ae unless i trade him out again?
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28424
Reputation : 21079
Join date : 2016-01-08
SI wrote:
Are they Edwards' NSW Cup minutes? If so, where did you get them?
was just a poster on the wests forum who attended the nsw cup game.
pm888- Posts : 1255
Reputation : 332
Join date : 2016-03-01
I see a lot of people trading out jsaifiti. Are you not considering keeping him as an extra player first bye round when the knights play? I can see its a bit tricky because there are 5 games between now and then./ Maybe im biased because I only have 9 players that round including him
I'm gonna hold as his breakeven appears to be 24 on the renegades page and he may potentially go above that
I'm gonna hold as his breakeven appears to be 24 on the renegades page and he may potentially go above that
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28424
Reputation : 21079
Join date : 2016-01-08
pm888 wrote:I see a lot of people trading out jsaifiti. Are you not considering keeping him as an extra player first bye round when the knights play? I can see its a bit tricky because there are 5 games between now and then./ Maybe im biased because I only have 9 players that round including him
I'm gonna hold as his breakeven appears to be 24 on the renegades page and he may potentially go above that
personally, i think he'll be starting again sooner rather than later. he's not a bad 'hold' at all.
in my case i'm trading him + carter to a keeper.