2017 NRL.com Fantasy Thread Part 56

Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

Anyone else think Mansour looked terrible last week?

I may bring him in on this basis.

Yep, 
Do
Cherry
Evans

Random wrote:Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

I'm wondering if its crazy holding Munster for two weeks.

Pain wrote:

Random wrote:Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

I'm wondering if its crazy holding Munster for two weeks.

Shh I am doing that one too.

TysonFrizellsBottomBitch wrote:Yep, 
Do
Cherry
Evans

How do you fit Backflip into that statement?

Pain wrote:

Random wrote:Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

I'm wondering if its crazy holding Munster for two weeks.

I've all but done Munster to Calker. Pocket 120k and hopefully 100 points. I will hate watching Munster play but it makes sense. Unless I ditch Slater instead. That might hurt a little less.

Pain wrote:
I'm wondering if its crazy holding Munster for two weeks.

I've traded him this week. Didn't want to but I need points for the next two rounds. Whether you trade him out will probably depend on how many trades you have left.

SI wrote:

I've all but done Munster to Calker.  Pocket 120k and hopefully 100 points.  I will hate watching Munster play but it makes sense.  Unless I ditch Slater instead.  That might hurt a little less.

I'm surprised you've chosen to trade Munster over Slater. I think I would've gone the other way.

Random wrote:

Shh I am doing that one too.

Munster to Mansour?

Munster >>> Slater all day

Spuddies wrote:

SI wrote:

I've all but done Munster to Calker.  Pocket 120k and hopefully 100 points.  I will hate watching Munster play but it makes sense.  Unless I ditch Slater instead.  That might hurt a little less.

I'm surprised you've chosen to trade Munster over Slater. I think I would've gone the other way.

This sentiment I would be holding Munster trading Slater, but to be honest it could just be a flip of the coin who ends up better choice season end so the cash in hand is probably better.

I could do Munster -> C. Walker and R. Tuivasa-Scheck -> N. Cleary/D. Cherry-Evans/T. Trbojevic/D. Edwards

How do people like the looks of that?

Pain wrote:

Random wrote:

Shh I am doing that one too.

Munster to Mansour?

I was looking at holding Munster. But if I trade him out I will go to Walker. It will give me some surplus cash to either upgrade J. Bromwich next week or upgrade B. French.

Everyone dumping RTS are they? high ownership to slightly better POD version I'm guessing?

Wish I had those trades

Random wrote:

This sentiment I would be holding Munster trading Slater, but to be honest it could just be a flip of the coin who ends up better choice season end so the cash in hand is probably better.

I could do Munster -> C. Walker and R. Tuivasa-Scheck -> N. Cleary/D. Cherry-Evans/T. Trbojevic/D. Edwards

How do people like the looks of that?

I'd definitely like to know the answer to that

plus why now all the CWalker love?

He was getting panned the other day

Random wrote:Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

I've been thinking the same thing mate, guys like RTS and Slater may become PODs with all the talk about trading them out.

With the aim of saving trades I'm seriously considering finishing the year with a back 4 of Munster, Slater, RTS and Edwards, they have just been so consistent and no reason to trade with the scores they've been posting.

If I did trade anyone it probably would be RTS for DCE so he can provide a bit of cover in the halves for me in case SJ or Cleary get injured.

Also Sash's team for this week.

mango wrote:

Random wrote:Firstly am I crazy for not trading out R. Tuivasa-Scheck this week?

I am thinking I only lose him this week, he will become more of a PoD in competitive teams as they trade him out this week and if Warriors fire and push for the Top 8 he could be a solid option. I was looking at trading him to either D. Cherry-Evans, T. Trbojevic, or D. Edwards for this week.

I could also just hold Tuivasa-Scheck this week and trade him to Tedesco either Round 19/20.

I've been thinking the same thing mate, guys like RTS and Slater may become PODs with all the talk about trading them out.

With the aim of saving trades I'm seriously considering finishing the year with a back 4 of Munster, Slater, RTS and Edwards, they have just been so consistent and no reason to trade with the scores they've been posting.

If I did trade anyone it probably would be RTS for DCE so he can provide a bit of cover in the halves for me in case SJ or Cleary get injured.

See for me I would go for Walker. Then I would have C. Walker, T. Lolohea and an NPR to swap between WFB's and HLF's.

If i ran with the above trades I would end up with a back four of C. Walker, T. Lolohea, T. Trbojevic most weeks with B. French (Unless I upgrade him) and J. Hayne as options to move around there.

Random wrote:

See for me I would go for Walker. Then I would have C. Walker, T. Lolohea and an NPR to swap between WFB's and HLF's.

If i ran with the above trades I would end up with a back four of C. Walker, T. Lolohea, T. Trbojevic most weeks with B. French (Unless I upgrade him) and J. Hayne as options to move around there.

Yeah the DPP swap between HLF and WFB is so handy to have.  I got rid of Walker last week, I didn't want him to lose anymore cash and he pulls out s 65 the prick! Now everyone is talking about trading him in, I'm not convinced , I still think his best position is in the halves.