Trade Game V1

@Big Diesel

De Belin for Guerra

Bren wrote:Yo Big Diesel I made you an offer on the previous page big boy.

That's nice.

SI wrote:

I've got that as slightly in your favour.  Throw in DCE for Moylan or Sutton and it's a dome deal.

Can we go Taupau instead of McGuire?
and throw in
Lyon -Walker/Mansour
Gillett - E Taylor?

@SI

Farah for Seggy

How are you going Beast? Find anything to finish off my previous offer?

Beast From The Big East wrote:@SI

Farah for Seggy

Seggy > Farah

Bren wrote:How are you going Beast? Find anything to finish off my previous offer?

Haven't sorry. I know you are after Graham but I'm just not willing to give him up for Tamou. Will be keeping him unless it's in a trade for another top tier prop

Bren wrote:

Seggy > Farah

No need for that on other peoples trades lad

Parcell - Elgey

Otherwise none of you bench guys get into my final squad

Beast From The Big East wrote:

Haven't sorry. I know you are after Graham but I'm just not willing to give him up for Tamou. Will be keeping him unless it's in a trade for another top tier prop

Both Graham and Scott are top tier props so they are a like for like in that regard. I see Morgan over Widdop especially when you take into account how well he did at Fullback last year then in the halves this year. Plus he made origin this year and held his own. So I would need a win somewhere for me to even it out.

Welshy87 wrote:

No need for that on other peoples trades lad

Parcell - Elgey

Otherwise none of you bench guys get into my final squad

Nothing to do with the trade offer more so to do with "Will Farah be playing first grade in 2016".

Also done deal on Parcell for Elgey. Thankyou. I now have the fastest hooking rotation in the comp (Granville and Parcell).

Bren wrote:

Both Graham and Scott are top tier props so they are a like for like in that regard. I see Morgan over Widdop especially when you take into account how well he did at Fullback last year then in the halves this year. Plus he made origin this year and held his own. So I would need a win somewhere for me to even it out.

Add in Whare for Hoffman? Or Croker for Linett depending on how you rate them. Or what else would you be after?

Bren wrote:

Nothing to do with the trade offer more so to do with "Will Farah be playing first grade in 2016".

Also done deal on Parcell for Elgey. Thankyou. I now have the fastest hooking rotation in the comp (Granville and Parcell).

No wrries glad i could finally facilitate your PArcell and Oates needs haha

You have to get rid of  one half of that lightning hooking rotation, unless you find a way to double back on Granville

Bren wrote:

Nothing to do with the trade offer more so to do with "Will Farah be playing first grade in 2016".

Also done deal on Parcell for Elgey. Thankyou. I now have the fastest hooking rotation in the comp (Granville and Parcell).

Farah's rating doesn't depend on team politics though. He has issues with management but can't deny he is still the blues incumbent and up there in top hookers in the game

Welshy87 wrote:

No wrries glad i could finally facilitate your PArcell and Oates needs haha

You have to get rid of  one half of that lightning hooking rotation, unless you find a way to double back on Granville

I wish I didn't get the Cowboys as I would be going hammer and tongs for blokes like Coote, Granville, Cooper, Tamou etc.

Bren wrote:

I wish I didn't get the Cowboys as I would be going hammer and tongs for blokes like Coote, Granville, Cooper, Tamou etc.

IMO

Coote is quality , good kicking game, sound enough defensivley and offers alot orchestrating attacks but he hasn't got that beat a team on his own play like the other top fullbacks have...Dugan, Tedesco, RTS, Milford, GI

Welshy87 wrote:

SI wrote:

I've got that as slightly in your favour.  Throw in DCE for Moylan or Sutton and it's a dome deal.

Can we go Taupau instead of McGuire?
and throw in
Lyon -Walker/Mansour
Gillett - E Taylor?

Taupau instead of McGuire+Lyon for Walker+DCE for Areyn?

SI wrote:

Taupau instead of McGuire+Lyon for Walker+DCE for Areyn?

Deal mate.

so

Parker - Merrin
Taupau - Gurgess
Lyon - Walker
DCE - A Reynolds

Beast From The Big East wrote:

Add in Whare for Hoffman? Or Croker for Linett depending on how you rate them. Or what else would you be after?

Used to rate Whare, now not so much.

Big Konrad Hurrell?

Big Diesel wrote:Big Konrad Hurrell?

Kane Linnett.