NRL Fantasy 2022 Part 42 - Tofu Haggis

mrbrownstone wrote:

At least Ese'ese is dirt cheap (still a very questionable buy). Suggesting Gildart - who has 50% of his scores in the teens this year - presumably because he scored a 53 with a try and three line-breaks last week is just insanity. 348k centre so priced at 25 and averaging 26.8. The justification was that he has a good draw, but the Tigers have got Cowboys, Dogs, Rabbitohs, Manly coming up, I wouldn't say that's a particularly favourable draw? Just weird, actively bad advice.

BCT05 wrote:Quite a bit of Schneider trade out talk, and he's been traded out for the community team.

Am I being overly optimistic that he is a hold for rd13? (unless he loses his spot of course which still seems unlikely to me). Two bad scores in a row but before that he was very solid. I have no plans to cut him loose just yet

mrbrownstone wrote:

At least Ese'ese is dirt cheap (still a very questionable buy). Suggesting Gildart - who has 50% of his scores in the teens this year - presumably because he scored a 53 with a try and three line-breaks last week is just insanity. 348k centre so priced at 25 and averaging 26.8. The justification was that he has a good draw, but the Tigers have got Cowboys, Dogs, Rabbitohs, Manly coming up, I wouldn't say that's a particularly favourable draw? Just weird, actively bad advice.

robelgordo wrote:

Oh wow, would've guessed Gildart was closer to 284k. I still wouldn't want him, but you'd possibly do it as a cashout to facilitate a gun who can be used in an emergency if he was sub-300k.

The previous Scouts knew the audience and wouldn't go there, or even make a case for a much more reasonable hunch/POD play (unless there were massive qualifiers). Because it's better to not take a shot than take it and miss in that gig I reckon

BCT05 wrote:Quite a bit of Schneider trade out talk, and he's been traded out for the community team.

Am I being overly optimistic that he is a hold for rd13? (unless he loses his spot of course which still seems unlikely to me). Two bad scores in a row but before that he was very solid. I have no plans to cut him loose just yet

BCT05 wrote:Quite a bit of Schneider trade out talk, and he's been traded out for the community team.

Am I being overly optimistic that he is a hold for rd13? (unless he loses his spot of course which still seems unlikely to me). Two bad scores in a row but before that he was very solid. I have no plans to cut him loose just yet

Milchcow wrote:

With Fogarty back soon, its not even a guarantee he'll play in round 13

Loomer wrote:

Fogarty back training. Schneider might not be in team for Rd 13. 45 BE. Could lose 20k that could be better put toward a cow or gun

FaringdonSwirl wrote:Think I've talked myself into Ponga. Lord have mercy.

Aardvark wrote:

Jalepenos?? It's far from Jalepenos you were born young man

Jumping Marlin wrote:Lone Scout has some views different.

> Burbo a must
> probably trade Staggs to Olam, Burton, Graham or Manu
> Tuipulotu, Gildart and Ese’ese best buys under $400k (apart from Burbo)
> sell Tuilagi soon
> Tigers are great on magic round
> lean to No on Elliott
> Hynes a great C option.  Match ups make him a bit low on Cleary and others
> sell Tago

ShadowSabre wrote:Who misses out on a bench spot out of this lot:

Tuilagi
Tago
Luki
King
Ilias

Loomer wrote:

Mr Snrub wrote:If you traded Burton out like I did, would you give any consideration to bringing him back as a keeper CTR or just deal with the fact you messed up and traded him out before his best scores.  

Are his sub 40 scores behind him or is the 52 and 82 the anomalies?