R17 trade talk
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
- Post n°1
R17 trade talk
Welsh Mafia- Posts : 2534
Reputation : 1467
Join date : 2021-02-27
Age : 32
Location : Christchurch
- Post n°2
Re: R17 trade talk
We could do with a little depth in the halves I think, or is the plan to bring back the Chin?
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13118
Reputation : 9659
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
- Post n°3
Re: R17 trade talk
Definitely think we trade those 3 and vow never to have 4 Bulldogs again.
On who comes IN, think we need to decide whether to push for R19 or just get longer-term picks. Below is just me thinking out loud, not a coherent strategy
R19 team as it currently stands (assuming 3 Bulldogs out)
x
Horse, JdB, Harris (Hopgood)
Preston, iPap (Matto)
Hynes SJ, (Niko)
NULL, x
Bula, x, x
So we have additional forwards, an additional half (Niko trade at R19?)
Need a hooker, centre, 2*WFB - if we wanted to aim for 13 in R19
But outside Bird (assuming he's fit), no real standouts to get right now in terms of players that are both R19 and keepers. Not sure we have trades to stuff about with R19 cash grabs we might get stuck with anyway. Should leave too late if we can.
So I think the focus should be Origin players we want as keepers that are good value. Preferably those with no byes left in the run home e.g. Grant, Munster/DCE, Yeo. Klese Haas as an enabler. Or Hands if Hodgson is long term out, helps with R19 (but also gives us 4 hookers)
On who comes IN, think we need to decide whether to push for R19 or just get longer-term picks. Below is just me thinking out loud, not a coherent strategy
R19 team as it currently stands (assuming 3 Bulldogs out)
x
Horse, JdB, Harris (Hopgood)
Preston, iPap (Matto)
Hynes SJ, (Niko)
NULL, x
Bula, x, x
So we have additional forwards, an additional half (Niko trade at R19?)
Need a hooker, centre, 2*WFB - if we wanted to aim for 13 in R19
But outside Bird (assuming he's fit), no real standouts to get right now in terms of players that are both R19 and keepers. Not sure we have trades to stuff about with R19 cash grabs we might get stuck with anyway. Should leave too late if we can.
So I think the focus should be Origin players we want as keepers that are good value. Preferably those with no byes left in the run home e.g. Grant, Munster/DCE, Yeo. Klese Haas as an enabler. Or Hands if Hodgson is long term out, helps with R19 (but also gives us 4 hookers)
Last edited by robelgordo on Tue Jun 20, 2023 1:41 pm; edited 2 times in total
Camo123- Fanatic
- Posts : 13186
Reputation : 9530
Join date : 2019-01-30
- Post n°4
Re: R17 trade talk
Currently 7 on bye + 3 to back up (would think all 3 back up pending Origin)
Edwards, Alamoti and Oloapu are clear trade outs. I would also probably sell Nikorima but may need Preston as more expensive
Need WFB/CTR, HLF and EDG I think. So would look at Bird, DCE/Munster, KHaas
Edwards, Alamoti and Oloapu are clear trade outs. I would also probably sell Nikorima but may need Preston as more expensive
Need WFB/CTR, HLF and EDG I think. So would look at Bird, DCE/Munster, KHaas
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13118
Reputation : 9659
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
- Post n°5
Re: R17 trade talk
I forgot to look at this week needs haha
Haven't done sums but getting the Bird, Munster, Khaas/Hands* for the three Bulldogs chumps while keeping a cash reserve for post R19 shopping spree would be nice
*depends on whether it's more important to have EDG cover now or HOK cover in R19 AND if Hodgson is confirmed done
Haven't done sums but getting the Bird, Munster, Khaas/Hands* for the three Bulldogs chumps while keeping a cash reserve for post R19 shopping spree would be nice
*depends on whether it's more important to have EDG cover now or HOK cover in R19 AND if Hodgson is confirmed done
Camo123- Fanatic
- Posts : 13186
Reputation : 9530
Join date : 2019-01-30
- Post n°6
Re: R17 trade talk
Actually we don’t need a specific EDG, forgot about Matto DPP
Pre trades the team can be set up like (assuming no injuries)
Robson
Horse JDB Harris
Hopgood Matto
Pre trades the team can be set up like (assuming no injuries)
Robson
Horse JDB Harris
Hopgood Matto
SJ Nikorima
Lemeulu Manu
Teddy Ponga
Turpin Cook (Edwards) (Alamoti)
(Oloapu) (Bula) (IPap) (Preston) (Hynes)
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13118
Reputation : 9659
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
- Post n°7
Re: R17 trade talk
Bird (move Manu to CTR)
Munster, assuming gets thru
Some 3rd player?
Munster, assuming gets thru
Some 3rd player?
rhinoceroo- Fanatic
- Posts : 14020
Reputation : 9265
Join date : 2015-09-30
- Post n°8
Re: R17 trade talk
Jed Cartwright is very useful as a 2rf this week and a centre in R19, assuming he keeps his spot for the next few weeks. Would probably target Haas (the real one) as an Origin gun, as long as he backs up.