NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 81 - Can the last green dot please turn off the lights

easytiger wrote:In other news; Paul Alamotti is heading to the Panthers.

I already get the feeling that losing SCritta is not even going to be a speed bump for them

Remind me to pick up Brad Schneider in the Origin period next year (he also moved to Panthers)

Panthers halfbacks filling in for Cleary are now a thing

Burton 2020 and 2021 without Cleary - 71.8 average (8 games)
O’Sullivan 2022 without Cleary (including Cleary send off game): 51.6 average (10 games)
Cogger 2023 average without Cleary 55.4 average (5 games)

easytiger wrote:In other news; Paul Alamotti is heading to the Panthers.

I already get the feeling that losing SCritta is not even going to be a speed bump for them

It's such an outstanding piece of business for Panthers

Crichton for Alamoti plus cap space (already being used to upgrade Edwards and probably others)

As good as Crichton is, one of Taylan May or Alamoti takes his spot and everything continues like clockwork. Both have the ceiling of becoming a superstar like Tago and Crichton before them. Meanwhile Crichton has to become the first Bulldogs recruit to not see their career go backwards while also proving himself in a new position.

Actually find it mindblowing that Bulldogs would mismanage an Origin U19 rep so badly that he's free to leave while still not 20. That seems like sub-Tigers/Dragons level. Almost guaranteed to gun it at the Panthers.

Camo123 wrote:

Remind me to pick up Brad Schneider in the Origin period next year (he also moved to Panthers)

Panthers halfbacks are now a thing

Burton 2021 without Cleary - 69.8 average (6 games)
O’Sullivan 2022 without Cleary (including Cleary send off game): 51.6 average (10 games)
Cogger 2023 average without Cleary 55.4 average (5 games)

Just jealous of the Panthers template. Until they find the next Cleary/Luai, just sign a low cost game manager to be understudy for one year. And guarantee both SOS and Cogger have seen their market value rise coming out of the deal as well.

Hey, is yafss down for everybody or just me?

I was hoping to archive my trade data but it is unavailable on the NRL site anymore and yafss isn't working either.

Robertneville wrote:Hey, is yafss down for everybody or just me?

I was hoping to archive my trade data but it is unavailable on the NRL site anymore and yafss isn't working either.

Yeah it is

Can use https://footystatistics.com/team_analyser.php

Sorry it's back, not sure what happened.

ynot wrote:Sorry it's back, not sure what happened.

Sorry mate, I was getting an early start on those tweaks for next year that you asked me to look at, I should have PM'd you first though, sorry again.

Good news is after spending all day on it, I managed to change the title font from Sans to Garamond as requested.

Would have though you were more a Comic Sans sort of guy....

Moanaman wrote:Would have though you were more a Comic Sans sort of guy....

I am definitely without humour.

robelgordo wrote:

It's such an outstanding piece of business for Panthers

Crichton for Alamoti plus cap space (already being used to upgrade Edwards and probably others)

As good as Crichton is, one of Taylan May or Alamoti takes his spot and everything continues like clockwork. Both have the ceiling of becoming a superstar like Tago and Crichton before them. Meanwhile Crichton has to become the first Bulldogs recruit to not see their career go backwards while also proving himself in a new position.

Actually find it mindblowing that Bulldogs would mismanage an Origin U19 rep so badly that he's free to leave while still not 20. That seems like sub-Tigers/Dragons level. Almost guaranteed to gun it at the Panthers.

You have to wonder what it says - you're an Origin U19 rep, but we don't think we have the coaching ability or resources to turn you into a quality NRL player - we'd rather just try and buy one from another factory that look like they know what they're doing.

IMO Crichton was looking unlikely to be a top 10 fullback across the handful of games I saw him play fullback at the Panthers - it seems difficult to imagine him elevating at (dare I say it) an inferior club.
At the moment it seems like the Panthers are on course to achieve a Storm-like ability to turn over their squad for sustained success.

robelgordo wrote:

Yeah it is

Can use https://footystatistics.com/team_analyser.php

Thanks, unfortunately it doesn't show the prices on there and I am lazy. I swear every year as soon as the season ends I turn my brain off and just stop thinking about fantasy after having been obsessing over it for the previous 6 months and always forget to take screenshots until it is too late.

ynot wrote:Sorry it's back, not sure what happened.

Still down for me

Robertneville wrote:

Thanks, unfortunately it doesn't show the prices on there and I am lazy. I swear every year as soon as the season ends I turn my brain off and just stop thinking about fantasy after having been obsessing over it for the previous 6 months and always forget to take screenshots until it is too late.

Ask and you shall... receive ? (check team_analyser.php now.. just updated it to show player prices at time of each trade).

On the Wighton thing I think what saved it from being 6-8 weeks was the fact that Gamble had his forearm pushing into his mouth and with his other hand was applying pressure to the neck area. I don’t think it was as bad as the Proctor one personally and I think 3 weeks is about right. Jack did not go out of his way to bite him it just happened in the heat of the moment and he had a little nibble on a forearm that was pushed into his mouth. I thought Wighton argued it as best he could and 3 weeks is about the right outcome.

my tv broke wrote:

Ask and you shall... receive ? (check team_analyser.php now.. just updated it to show player prices at time of each trade).

Holy shit, you're a legend!

Thank you, just saved me hours of work.

Camo123 wrote:

Remind me to pick up Brad Schneider in the Origin period next year (he also moved to Panthers)

Panthers halfbacks filling in for Cleary are now a thing

Burton 2020 and 2021 without Cleary - 71.8 average (8 games)
O’Sullivan 2022 without Cleary (including Cleary send off game): 51.6 average (10 games)
Cogger 2023 average without Cleary 55.4 average (5 games)

So if Cleary ever leaves the Panthers system... are we expecting his fantasy output to drop?

Chewie wrote:

So if Cleary ever leaves the Panthers system... are we expecting his fantasy output to drop?

Cleary definitely benefits from the Panthers system in my opinion. It also helps that his dad selects him over other options in the squad. #nepotism

Chewie wrote:

So if Cleary ever leaves the Panthers system... are we expecting his fantasy output to drop?

There's an alternate world where Nathan joins Ivan at the Tigers, rather than the other way around.

Then you would have seen how far Nathan can fall.

Milchcow wrote:

There's an alternate world where Nathan joins Ivan at the Tigers, rather than the other way around.

Then you would have seen how far Nathan can fall.

as in a different timeline in the multiverse? Wow!
Does Brooks play for the Panthers in that alernate world?

Brooks is the NSW 5/8