NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 17 - He haas a sore knee

RandomSil wrote:

Based on?

Haas has only played less than 40 minutes 5 times in his career for the Broncos

Two injury games and 3 when he came off the bench in 2018.

He has three games between 40-50 minutes and averages 65. The guy is a workhorse even returning from injuries

His AC joint injury he played through, killed his scores, was averging 50 odd and had reduce minutes. Back end of 2022.

Hi everyone - what do you think on these two trades:

Haas out ---> Terrell in
Fogarty out --> Hynes in

leaves me $168 in bank (currently got $117k)

Reasoning: Haas is out one game (minimum), even if he comes back next week he might not be 100%

Hynes has a bye coming, but effectively Haas is playing a bye this week. And Hynes (C) is perfect to cover the Chin when he has his bye.

Fogs not a sell at all, done a really good job....... however Hynes is super upgrade on him. obviously

Thoughts?

Jason Punching wrote:Hi everyone - what do you think on these two trades:

Haas out ---> Terrell in
Fogarty out --> Hynes in

leaves me $168 in bank (currently got $117k)

Reasoning: Haas is out one game (minimum), even if he comes back next week he might not be 100%

Hynes has a bye coming, but effectively Haas is playing a bye this week. And Hynes (C) is perfect to cover the Chin when he has his bye.

Fogs not a sell at all, done a really good job....... however Hynes is super upgrade on him. obviously

Thoughts?

Trading out Fog might be the most insane trade idea I've ever heard.

Nothing structurally wrong with Haas though it’s patella pain do we think it’s just one week?

Consulting specialist doesn’t sound great though

If he has ongoing pain to manage, that's not ideal....

wolfking wrote:

Trading out Fog might be the most insane trade idea I've ever heard.

What about trading in Kiraz.

wolfking wrote:

Trading out Fog might be the most insane trade idea I've ever heard.

yeh, it's a pretty out there idea.

I should probably be conservative and hold Payne

Something worth mentioning is Haas went down the tunnel during the game to have his knee assessed but went back out and it didn't look to have impacted his performance that much if at all. As we know Haas' knee scans haven't revealed any structural issues.

Trading Haas to Hynes is objectively the same given Hynes has his bye coming up, so why not call this Haas' bye?

My final though re Haas is, you spend 1 trade now to sell, another to buy back and potentially another at the back end of the year when he's potentially getting rested. But by that stage, you've burnt all your trades trading out players with 1 week injuries.

I don't know what I'm going to do but this is my thought process right now. If Haas isn't back for R4 then he might be shown the door.

Rabbits21 wrote:Nothing structurally wrong with Haas though it’s patella pain do we think it’s just one week?

Consulting specialist doesn’t sound great though

If he has ongoing pain to manage, that's not ideal....

yep that's what is in my mind. He played through ongoing pain a season or two back IIRC. his scoring was affected.

CorruptSquid wrote:Something worth mentioning is Haas went down the tunnel during the game to have his knee assessed but went back out and it didn't look to have impacted his performance that much if at all. As we know Haas' knee scans haven't revealed any structural issues.

Trading Haas to Hynes is objectively the same given Hynes has his bye coming up, so why not call this Haas' bye?

My final though re Haas is, you spend 1 trade now to sell, another to buy back and potentially another at the back end of the year when he's potentially getting rested. But by that stage, you've burnt all your trades trading out players with 1 week injuries.

I don't know what I'm going to do but this is my thought process right now. If Haas isn't back for R4 then he might be shown the door.

thanks mate. this does make sense. I am just thinking of ways to get some cash to other areas of my team... but the bigger picture as you outline could end up being more harmful than the short term positive.

Hmm, food for thought over next couple of days.

Jason Punching wrote:

yep that's what is in my mind. He played through ongoing pain a season or two back IIRC. his scoring was affected.

That was shoulder this time knee

If I had Haas I wouldn't be selling. Would you be selling if he was on a bye?

Patella tendonitis….just whack a bit of tape under your knee and away you go! Job done….75 next week from the big fella

Snatchpato wrote:If I had Haas I wouldn't be selling. Would you be selling if he was on a bye?

What if it was to Hynes?

Snatchpato wrote:If I had Haas I wouldn't be selling. Would you be selling if he was on a bye?

I have Haas and am not selling unless we get clearer info of a long term issue.

Loomer wrote:

What if it was to Hynes?

I dunno man, bye in round 5, one of them is going to miss a round in the next 3 weeks anyway, why not save a trade and make it this round?

Haas is definitely a hold.



But Haas/Wong gets me Hynes/Curran with $0 left over. Talk me off the ledge

Mulvy wrote:Did we get to the bottom of why Cook came off with 10 to go last week?

Did he have an injury or was it #demetrioureasons?

I haven't heard or seen anything, but I could've sworn he was clutching his ribs before he was taken off.

I might go and rewatch the footage - I just recall thinking this better not be the old rib cartilage injury
I suspect it maybe was just a solid contact and got winded or something, and the match was already gone so coach put him in cotton wool?

Although, it's all probably irrelevant with Haas out now too as I certainly wouldn't have the luxury of trading a green dot on suspicion of something

Willison in the 17 for Haas. At 263k could be an interesting cashie, especially if he kicks on from here and forces his way into the team for Taupau or another forward.

I couldn't tell if the theme on p51 was of injury or a Salmon flopping 0n the ground, out of water.

Snatchpato wrote:If I had Haas I wouldn't be selling. Would you be selling if he was on a bye?

Difference being a bye is a certainty of 1 week. No guarantee of that here and no guarantee that scoring isn't affected if he does return next week.

I'll probably be holding but just saying it's not quite the same as a bye.