NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 19 - Souffs best fullback Owen Craigie or Owen Three ?

Kiraz downdated back to 89

There’s got to be an investigation

Camo123 wrote:Kiraz downdated back to 89

There’s got to be an investigation

Say what!?

First! Open!

The whole HIA testing process needs revisiting. Some guys will always fail on the basis of not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

Camo123 wrote:Kiraz downdated back to 89

There’s got to be an investigation

What are these stats monkeys up to? That's nearly 20 points I'm down since yesterday!

Perfect cash from Sitili to Tohu

Khany wrote:The whole HIA testing process needs revisiting.  Some guys will always fail on the basis of not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

Someone clarify for me also, just because someone gets a knock to the head, but shows no signs of being affected, he can still have to go through the hia process based on just having had a knock ??

Pookus McFly wrote:First! Open!

Lovely to finally see the cash gen rolling in

Galvin, Koroisau, Kiraz, Papenhuyzen, May all with 40k+ rise and Rapana, Fogarty, Salmon all with 30k+

Hosking owners loving life already making 150k and a straight swap to gun next week if still on bench

Jeez dropped about 900 places from yesterday to 3.4k

Camo123 wrote:Kiraz downdated back to 89

There’s got to be an investigation

Booooooooo

Goodnight Kiwi wrote:Perfect cash from Sitili to Tohu

But I need to prioritise Mr Fine, maybe KPP and am down a CTR/WFB for the 3rd time in 4 weeks

Walsh -> ponga
Safiti -> Carrigan

Hoping someone can fill me in regarding HIAs. I thought if you failed one on the weekend that automatically ruled you out for next week?

I was just reading casualty ward on NRL.com and it said Roosters are hopeful Sam Walker will be cleared to play this week. I felt a little rumble in my pants and kept reading down the page and found my mate, Tuaupiki, and it said he is “unlikely to be available” this week, which - because I’m a desperate gronk - gives me hope that there is still a chance he will play.

But this is all rubbish info, isn’t it? Neither Walker or Tuaupiki will participate in NRL this weekend, will they? No ifs or buts?

I remember there was someone last year… was it CNK? Someone seemed to defy a couple of these HIA bans through the year.

Anyone know the deal?

Teeth Eater wrote:Hoping someone can fill me in regarding HIAs. I thought if you failed one on the weekend that automatically ruled you out for next week?

I was just reading casualty ward on NRL.com and it said Roosters are hopeful Sam Walker will be cleared to play this week. I felt a little rumble in my pants and kept reading down the page and found my mate, Tuaupiki, and it said he is “unlikely to be available” this week, which - because I’m a desperate gronk - gives me hope that there is still a chance he will play.

But this is all rubbish info, isn’t it? Neither Walker or Tuaupiki will participate in NRL this weekend, will they? No ifs or buts?

I remember there was someone last year… was it CNK? Someone seemed to defy a couple of these HIA bans through the year.

Anyone know the deal?

Roosters already appealed the category for Walkers HIA and had it downgraded.. or something.. this was posted on roosters forum

"Just reported on channel 9 that the Roosters request to have Sammy exempt from category 1 protocols has been approved. Apparently he passed all concussion tests on the night."

he was holding his neck on the field after it happened.. so maybe just wasn't a head knock? i dunno, wasnt paying that much attention.

Sitili > Koro
Wong/Levi > Galvin

Time to suck it up

Sitili -> Campbell should be an easy trade if named.

Teeth Eater wrote:Hoping someone can fill me in regarding HIAs. I thought if you failed one on the weekend that automatically ruled you out for next week?

I was just reading casualty ward on NRL.com and it said Roosters are hopeful Sam Walker will be cleared to play this week. I felt a little rumble in my pants and kept reading down the page and found my mate, Tuaupiki, and it said he is “unlikely to be available” this week, which - because I’m a desperate gronk - gives me hope that there is still a chance he will play.

But this is all rubbish info, isn’t it? Neither Walker or Tuaupiki will participate in NRL this weekend, will they? No ifs or buts?

I remember there was someone last year… was it CNK? Someone seemed to defy a couple of these HIA bans through the year.

Anyone know the deal?

Standard procedure is 11 day stand down but its possible to apply for an exemption if a number of criteria are met (no category 1 symptoms, no concussion in last 3 months, no symptoms on the following day, less than a certain number of concussions in career)

my tv broke wrote:

Roosters already appealed the category for Walkers HIA and had it downgraded.. or something.. this was posted on roosters forum

"Just reported on channel 9 that the Roosters request to have Sammy exempt from category 1 protocols has been approved. Apparently he passed all concussion tests on the night."

he was holding his neck on the field after it happened.. so maybe just wasn't a head knock? i dunno, wasnt paying that much attention.

Interesting. Was it Turbo who had a similar situation last year?

So I wonder if Warriors have tried to appeal Tuaupiki decision to? That would make my week if he was somehow free, and then also picked to play.

Hmm, have to get a WFB this week so I think I’m going straight for Turbo, only issue is that I should probably concede that Terrell is a must-have and the only realistic path forward to get both while getting rid of Wong is either Smithies or Cheese out.

Broncos have players Sailor and Mariner. Why does no one talk about this