NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 19 - Souffs best fullback Owen Craigie or Owen Three ?

Captain Turbo, VC May

Snatchpato wrote:Didn't NRLphysio say Cleary's hamstring return could be 2-4 weeks? I wouldn't be shocked if Cleary was back in R7. Reckon I'll just hold him for 3 weeks.

Then again, Turbo.

Cleary himself was quoted saying he's a small chance of playing next week but more likely back R7.

I'm willing to hold him to then, I can get the same guys I want either way - I. Katoa and Pearce-Paul this week, then Ponga next week.

Damn, everyone holding Cleary now?

I'll 100% be selling

Bethany_B wrote:

Cleary himself was quoted saying he's a small chance of playing next week but more likely back R7.

I'm willing to hold him to then, I can get the same guys I want either way - I. Katoa and Pearce-Paul this week, then Ponga next week.

So he only misses two more weeks than we expected with bye? Kind of a hold if you have other fires (I have other fires)

Another snippet from NRLPhysio

Sandon Smith suffered a “significant medial ligament injury” to his elbow in Rd 3. Crazy effort as he played over 40 minutes with the injury - unstrapped!

Thankfully even complete UCL tears in non-throwing athletes rarely require surgery, but if torn most = 3-6 weeks recovery.

lukeayee wrote:

Kiraz if you have him, Dom young if you trade him in.

Captain Teddy.

rhinoceroo wrote:

So he only misses two more weeks than we expected with bye? Kind of a hold if you have other fires (I have other fires)

Cleary is awkward to get back in if you sell him. 2 trades and coming into Origin period.

Did I miss the Cow’s black label breakeven sheet today?

Brailey is going to be a good pick up when he is starting HOK again.

Chewie wrote:

That's it.
I'm flying back to Kashyyyk

Drop me in the oceans of Kashyyyk on ur way through...

I will blow two trades any day of the week over fucking around and finding out with a $950k marquee player's nebulous hamstring injury pre-origin

I holding Cleary purely because I also have Moses. Apparently, Cleary was suggesting he might be back next week - so if that is the case, I am laughing...

I can re-assess next week. I will be so happy if Schuster comes back as he can also fill half so I can play Galvan and Schuster, but I suspect he won't.

I am lucky that I only have Pap from the Storm and no other concerns besides Cotric. If Talagi is playing and Schuster is in

Moses to Randall

and

Cotric to Talagi is on the cards

Wonder how many accidental captains there will be this week after the Cleary trades..

Also don't listen to me I traded in Lussick and Cotter last week

I can go:

Cleary + Jaifiti > Fogarty + Turbo

Honestly for 3 weeks it's probably the go. I think I've been lucky to dodge a Turbo monster score thus far, and really want him in my side. Fogarty can hold the halves fort while Cleary is gone and hopefully bridge the coin gap in the next few weeks.

This early in the season and the way even serious people play, I don't see why their wouldn't be loads willing to both trade Cleary out and back in prior to origin. Sure it's a waste on paper, but people will burn, oh will they burn..... !

Is the Walsh % ownership still correct being that high ??

Revraiser wrote:Is the Walsh % ownership still correct being that high ??

I will bash you

Cleary out for 3 weeks is a sell, particularly seeing as I've saved a trade on most main players by not starting with Haas. I think there's <50% chance they risk him 1 round before the bye, seems like madness.

The trade out options are abundant though, I think I might keep Sitili (provided he starts) and trade someone like Levi/Shoes to Turbo or KPP.