2017 NRL.com Fantasy thread part 49

Slater>Cody really works for rest of my bye shuffling. Do we think he can bounce back points wise against Titans? One of key reasons his scores are down is making about 15 less tackles at fullback vs half

@Rippin and Tearin i like how you think! may go JWH after 19, shame no dual poisition to switch out

SaveTheCheerleader wrote:Ok, forgive this, doing a lot of thinking out loud!


Two this week:

Frawley -> Laybutt
Jennings -> Scott

leaves me with

Smith Brailey
McGuire Gurgess JWH Matagi
Taumalolo Surgess Gallen JDB Crichton Elliot
Norman Munster Walker Laybutt
Fuimaono BJ SMata Scott
Radradra Cotric RTS Edwards MWZ

Rank 1800, 9 trades left, $445k in the bank

Round 16
McGuire ($465) -> Taupau ($559) ~100k
Cotric ($370) -> TT ($414) ~45k

7 trades left, $300k bank

Round 18
Smith Brailey
Taupau Gurgess JWH Nuffie
Taumalolo Surgess Gallen JDB Crichton Elliot
Norman Munster Walker Laybutt
Fuimaono BJ SMata Scott
Radradra RTS TT MWZ Edwards

Round 19
Gurgess ($241) -> Nuffie ($138) ~+100k
Matagi ($238) -> Fifita ($557) ~319

Smith Brailey
Taupau Fifita JWH Nuffie
Taumalolo Surgess Gallen JDB Crichton Elliot
Norman Munster Walker Laybutt
Fuimaono BJ SMata Scott
Radradra RTS TT MWZ Edwards

5 trades left, $81k bank


Round ???
Brailey ($346) -> Nuffie ($138) ~+200k
MWZ ($162)- > Rapana ($519) ~360k

- Short 100k

Final team ??

Smith
Taupau Fifita JWH
Taumalolo Surgess Gallen JDB Crichton Elliot
Norman Munster Walker
Fuimaono BJ SMata
Radradra RTS TT Rapana Edwards

Thoughts ?!?

Running 1 hooker and guys like fui, semi, jwh as a final 17 makes my heart break.

I can understand why you want to keep certain players like SMat for the remaining byes but if he's going to be giving you crap like 25-35ppg for the 16-19 (which equals 100-140points in those 4 games) then your better off upgrading asap to a keeper gun with 1 bye left like JRoberts who will give you 40-50ppg = 120-150 points.

Ok breakdown time. Picking out the guys from your r15 team who shouldn't be in the final 17:
Brailey, Gurgess, JWH , Matagi , SMat , Fui , Semi

Round 15.
Your trades for this round are good. I'll add JWH as a trade out since he's the only one who plays one more bye. Trade him out to NBrown who is fine for a keeper 17, gives you two good byes and his price is good.
banked cash = $405k

Round 16
the person to target in this round is Matagi. With those numbers you should be glad to see the back of him. Get your man Taupau in for him.
Smat is the 2017 version of aubbs. Cotric has been great. Smat -> TTurbo
Bank = $40k

Round 19
Semi -> dpp half/wfb newbie so you can move walker/munster up and down . Bank = $220k
I'd rather the safety of two hookers so I'd do Brailey to McInnes in r19 or sooner if Mortimer/Seggy is a danger to his minutes.


Your r19 team should look like
Smith, McInnes,
Taupau, McGuire, NBrown, npr Gurgess
Lolo, Surgess, Gtrain, JDB, Chrichton, npr Elliot
Norman, Munster, npr Walker, npr laybutt
BJ, Cotric, npr fuimaono, npr scott
TTurbo, RTS, Edwards, npr MWZ , npr half/wfb

I think that is a more balanced team and you still have cashouts in AElliot,Gurgess, Fuimaono, if you want to upgrade McGuire and/or Cotric

SaveTheCheerleader wrote:@Rippin and Tearin i like how you think! may go JWH after 19, shame no dual poisition to switch out

Haha, but I was thinking 99% the way you were! Wait..... Hold on I see what you did there

dammit, Fogarty not playing...think i might make the trade anyway, the DPP is super-important for my final team plans.

surmo13 wrote:dammit, Fogarty not playing...think i might make the trade anyway, the DPP is super-important for my final team plans.

?

Chewie wrote:

?

Didn't train. Wasn't in 17 anyway. Don't know why people got their hopes up

Loomer wrote:

Didn't train. Wasn't in 17 anyway. Don't know why people got their hopes up

well, Henry said himself he was a chance to come in if they got clearance from NRL etc

itsJay wrote:

Running 1 hooker and guys like fui, semi, jwh as a final 17 makes my heart break.

I can understand why you want to keep certain players like SMat for the remaining byes but if he's going to be giving you crap like 25-35ppg for the 16-19 (which equals 100-140points in those 4 games) then your better off upgrading asap to a keeper gun with 1 bye left like JRoberts who will give you 40-50ppg = 120-150 points.

Ok breakdown time. Picking out the guys from your r15 team who shouldn't be in the final 17:
Brailey, Gurgess, JWH , Matagi , SMat , Fui , Semi

Round 15.
Your trades for this round are good. I'll add JWH as a trade out since he's the only one who plays one more bye. Trade him out to NBrown who is fine for a keeper 17, gives you two good byes and his price is good.
banked cash = $405k

Round 16
the person to target in this round is Matagi. With those numbers you should be glad to see the back of him. Get your man Taupau in for him.
Smat is the 2017 version of aubbs. Cotric has been great. Smat -> TTurbo
Bank = $40k

Round 19
Semi -> dpp half/wfb newbie so you can move walker/munster up and down . Bank = $220k
I'd rather the safety of two hookers so I'd do Brailey to McInnes in r19 or sooner if Mortimer/Seggy is a danger to his minutes.


Your r19 team should look like
Smith, McInnes,
Taupau, McGuire, NBrown, npr Gurgess
Lolo, Surgess, Gtrain, JDB, Chrichton, npr Elliot
Norman, Munster, npr Walker, npr laybutt
BJ, Cotric, npr fuimaono, npr scott
TTurbo, RTS, Edwards, npr MWZ , npr half/wfb

I think that is a more balanced team and you still have cashouts in AElliot,Gurgess, Fuimaono, if you want to upgrade McGuire and/or Cotric

i like the way you think , it just pains me get NBrown as i booted him (*but to be fair, i booted him at top dollar $443) when he got injured.

Nice analysis, appreciate it! Food for thought.

SI wrote:
You are kind of replacing a bloke who posts 2 scores for you in the next 5 weeks with another if you go Slater to Pearce.  Not saying don't do it, but when figuring that in plus the extra cash it seems sideways at the moment.  Norman gives you the extra game but probably no more points so same scenario.

Replaced Slater with Edwards will trade Walker eventually to Pearce. If he doesn't pick up this game maybe round 20.

Loomer wrote:

Didn't train. Wasn't in 17 anyway. Don't know why people got their hopes up

bottom dollar halfback with dpp and a chance of playing a major bye... that got my hopes up

Chewie wrote:

bottom dollar halfback with dpp and a chance of playing a major bye... that got my hopes up

I'd like a cashout but I think getting Walker gives me bye numbers where I need them. Can he score well again is the question

Nrl4Life wrote:

SI wrote:
You are kind of replacing a bloke who posts 2 scores for you in the next 5 weeks with another if you go Slater to Pearce.  Not saying don't do it, but when figuring that in plus the extra cash it seems sideways at the moment.  Norman gives you the extra game but probably no more points so same scenario.

Replaced Slater with Edwards will trade Walker eventually to Pearce. If he doesn't pick up this game maybe round 20.

Slater>Edwards should prove a very good trade.  I am potentially doing it next round.

Loomer wrote:

Chewie wrote:

?

Didn't train. Wasn't in 17 anyway. Don't know why people got their hopes up

I don't have him, but with all the Titans injuries and the way it was rushed, seemed it was going to happen.

SI wrote:
I don't have him, but with all the Titans injuries and the way it was rushed, seemed it was going to happen.

What do you think of Slater>Walker? Works so well for rest of my byes

Loomer wrote:

SI wrote:
I don't have him, but with all the Titans injuries and the way it was rushed, seemed it was going to happen.

What do you think of Slater>Walker? Works so well for rest of my  byes

I think it's worth the risk v reward with bye numbers.  I had Calker all but in my team a month ago but reversed at the last minute with the contract chat.  Would love him for the run home IF he comes good.

Will Matty Moylan stay in the halves?

Got him 2 weeks ago and could be a good alternative for the WFB for the run in.

Welshy wrote:Will Matty Moylan stay in the halves?

Got him 2 weeks ago and could be a good alternative for the WFB for the run in.

Yeah, good call.  You'd thin he would but when is Carty back?

Loomer wrote:

His base stats last 2 games are 20 from his run metres. These are great run metres but great base stats?

Tbs are base stats for Mansour. Had consistently gotten them since coming into first grade

SI wrote:
Yeah, good call.  You'd thin he would but when is Carty back?

original call was 6-8 weeks wasn't it?

Griffin would need to think looong and hard about throwing Cartwright back into the halves mix, 1 crushing win against the dogs and a very good win against a quality raiders team with Moylan in the 6

Surely Griffin isn't that dull