Trade Game V1

Not that I don't rate Munster, but just he doesn't add anything to my squad with that trade. Don't need him at FB so he'd just be chucked out on the wing so loses a lot of value there.

@Bren

i know how much you love Blair

add him into a little JT - SJ deal

Welshy87 wrote:@Bren

i know how much you love Blair

add him into a little JT - SJ deal

I think you are mistaken. I love McGuire more then Blair. Blair did okay in McGuire's absence.

For shits and giggles.

Thurston - SJ
Jackson - Gillett
Jennings - Dugan
?? - ??

Honeysett wrote:

I understand the drop in quality for lane and Gillett is the same as Matulino but if you offered me Gillett for Big Ben which this effectively is  for me I'd say no

all about team make up mate and see where you are coming from

thought Mannah is quality starting prop
and Gillet slots right into the edge defender you need

so you gained 2 quality starters while i upgrade Gillett to Matulino and move a ressy prop onto my bench

Bren wrote:

I think you are mistaken. I love McGuire more then Blair. Blair did okay in McGuire's absence.

For shits and giggles.

Thurston - SJ
Jackson - Gillett
Jennings - Dugan
?? - ??

you rate McGuire over Blair...Really....

Welshy87 wrote:

you rate McGuire over Blair...Really....

So did many for the past few seasons while he stunk it up at the Tigers. McGuire can play prop, lock and hooker. I bet he could even play fullback

Bren wrote:

So did many for the past few seasons while he stunk it up at the Tigers. McGuire can play prop, lock and hooker. I bet he could even play fullback

love McGuire, quality player!

Beast From The Big East wrote:Not that I don't rate Munster, but just he doesn't add anything to my squad with that trade. Don't need him at FB so he'd just be chucked out on the wing so loses a lot of value there.

so J. Bird doesn't change that trade then?

Welshy87 wrote:

all about team make up mate and see where you are coming from

thought Mannah is quality starting prop
and Gillet slots right into the edge defender you need

so you gained 2 quality starters while i upgrade Gillett to Matulino and move a ressy prop onto my bench

See I think Matulino plays better at prop and I'm light on them, I don't need second rowers. I've got some guns my disposal

Welshy87 wrote:

so J. Bird doesn't change that trade then?

Na. Still throws out team balance having to throw Bird, Croker or Whare on the wing.

Who has Trex?

Honeysett wrote:

See I think Matulino plays better at prop and I'm light on them, I don't need second rowers. I've got some guns my disposal

agree better at prop, he would be taking Gillett's second row spot in my team, thought you could of moved Mannah to starting prop, dropped Gillett into 12 and used Napa off the bench.

fine lad!

still waiting on SI until we can re visit the Korisau - Rochow trade?

Bren wrote:Who has Trex?

I could do. Who you throwing up?

Also who do you want for Lane Honeysett?

I want Trex on the wing. Try stopping Hurrell and Trex together. Phwoar.

Welshy87 wrote:

agree better at prop, he would be taking Gillett's second row spot in my team, thought you could of moved Mannah to starting prop, dropped Gillett into 12 and used Napa off the bench.

fine lad!

still waiting on SI until we can re visit the Korisau - Rochow trade?

Let's do it. Done.

Honeysett wrote:

Let's do it. Done.

yay i finally got Matulino

Welshy87 wrote:

yay i finally got Matulino  

Get off the drugs

Honeysett wrote:

Get off the drugs

haha

as a Knights fan

what are your thoughts on Rochow?

Welshy87 wrote:

haha

as a Knights fan

what are your thoughts on Rochow?

Extremely solid talent with great potential who will never play rep football. Won me over $1000 on a second try first try scorer so comes highly recommended