NRL Fantasy 2020 Part 18 - Ditch the duds thread

Probably 2 sides of the same coin, but Wiliame at centre vs Lomax on the wing?

Bethany_B wrote:Thoughts on which combo is better? I'm getting Hughes in for Tuala and the options below would fund that trade

TU: Knight-> Katoa

TD: Friend -> Guler

Anyone else? I don't really like losing either of those

Is anyone who has Stimson holding him?

I can see him scoring a couple of 40ish scores but inbetween that with 20’s is it gonna be enough?

I think he could be a frustrating slow burn cash maker and I’m not sure I can sit back and watch it unfold at a slow rate.

SoylentGreen wrote:Probably 2 sides of the same coin, but Wiliame at centre vs Lomax on the wing?

I know Wiliame nearly scored twice but Friz refused to pass all game and they went right so much more.

Rabbits21 wrote:Is anyone who has Stimson holding him?

I can see him scoring a couple of 40ish scores but inbetween that with 20’s is it gonna be enough?

I think he could be a frustrating slow burn cash maker and I’m not sure I can sit back and watch it unfold at a slow rate.

His average as a starting 2RF playing 70+ minutes is 42, no reason to think he won't emulate that

Welshy wrote:

I know Wiliame nearly scored twice but Friz refused to pass all game and they went right so much more.

Cheers. Neither option excited me

Welshy wrote:


Plus it severely weakens my WFB so that’s out

Cheers boys

Will look at moving Friend on for Cleary, really want to keep JMK as there money to be made there and I’m expecting 48 average longer term

Stimson to katoa is an option and you keep JMK.

SoylentGreen wrote:

Cheers. Neither option excited me

Looked promising at the start but Dragons were so middle concentric when they had the ball, just didn't look like he was having any sort of opportunity

But I still like him long term in NPRs, was good in SL and been talked up a few times by teammates in pre season

I don’t know why the feeling is so strong but my gut is telling me to get Cleary in for Moses

WT2K wrote:

Stimson to katoa is an option and you keep JMK.

Might have to build some cash to get Cleary. Considering

Musgrove - Guler
Wiliame - Katoa

short term cash generation but leaves me short on WFB cover, plus I think Wiliame comes good

Welshy wrote:

Anyone else? I don't really like losing either of those

I'll give you my full side, I don't really see any other options unless I want to punt Arrow, but his low mins was from an illness so hopefully he's supposed to get more than 53 mins.

Friend
Haas, Knight
Lolo, Arrow, Lucy
Mann, Croft
Watkins, Tuala
Papy, Drinky, Lomax

Api, Brailey, Carrigan, Walters

Luai, Musgrove, Rudolf, Wiliame

$20k ITB

Welshy wrote:

His average as a starting 2RF playing 70+ minutes is 42, no reason to think he won't emulate that

Just the lure of moving Wiliame to my EMG with these trades may be too hard for me to resist.

Rabbits21 wrote:Is anyone who has Stimson holding him?

I can see him scoring a couple of 40ish scores but inbetween that with 20’s is it gonna be enough?

I think he could be a frustrating slow burn cash maker and I’m not sure I can sit back and watch it unfold at a slow rate.

I'm giving Ese'Ese, Hess, Stimson and wakeham all another week. I didn't bring any of them in expecting to play them for one game unless their position in the 17 changed. I still see them all having the ability to put in enough of a score to reset them back to a low BE and start making $$$ again.

I may just go with a Musgrove to Katoa trade and leave it at that and hold Stimson another week.

Who would you play in your 17 out of the following three? (Can only play 2)

Stimson
Katoa
Walters

SoylentGreen wrote:Probably 2 sides of the same coin, but Wiliame at centre vs Lomax on the wing?

Have them both and you can't lose!!!

Bethany_B wrote:

I'll give you my full side, I don't really see any other options unless I want to punt Arrow, but his low mins was from an illness so hopefully he's supposed to get more than 53 mins.

Friend
Haas, Knight
Lolo, Arrow, Lucy
Mann, Croft
Watkins, Tuala
Papy, Drinky, Lomax

Api, Brailey, Carrigan, Walters

Luai, Musgrove, Rudolf, Wiliame

$20k ITB

See what you mean tough and might have to give up someone still making money and scoring well. Not worth moving Arrow for sure

Does Tuala to nuff give you the cash to go Lomax - Hughes? and play Wiliame CTR. I doubt it

Welshy wrote:

Might have to build some cash to get Cleary. Considering

Musgrove - Guler
Wiliame - Katoa

short term cash generation but leaves me short on WFB cover, plus I think Wiliame comes good

Then just go Musgrove to Katoa mate

Bethany_B wrote:

I'll give you my full side, I don't really see any other options unless I want to punt Arrow, but his low mins was from an illness so hopefully he's supposed to get more than 53 mins.

Friend
Haas, Knight
Lolo, Arrow, Lucy
Mann, Croft
Watkins, Tuala
Papy, Drinky, Lomax

Api, Brailey, Carrigan, Walters

Luai, Musgrove, Rudolf, Wiliame

$20k ITB

You need a gun half. You should look at Arrow to Horsbourgh and Friend to your choice of gun half

Donkeyyyyyy wrote:
Then just go Musgrove to Katoa mate

That’s what I’m doing!

Lock it in!

Now who to leave out, out of Stimson, Walters and Katoa?.....

Donkeyyyyyy wrote:
Then just go Musgrove to Katoa mate

Yea I might have to play the waiting game and grab Guler and Katoa for quick cash and wait a week on Cleary

or I can go now

Friend - Cleary
Stimson - Katoa