NRLFF 2006 Fantasy thread - part 2 Let's get ready to rumble

multiple.scoregasms wrote:Let's get some discussion going

Brett Hodgson vs Clinton Schifcofske, do you want the consistency of Schifcofske or the upside from Hodgson?

Mark Gasnier vs Matt Cooper, the flashy attack of Gasnier vs the reliable defense of Cooper?

Do you pay the premium for Kurt Gidley given he averages 11 higher than the next best half? Or do you chase some value?

Which tackle bot 2RF do you want? Paul Gallen, Craig Fitzgibbon, Ben Kennedy

Do you go with future fantasy immortal Corey Parker or the already established Dallas Johnson?

Do you lock in a work horse prop like Shane Webcke, Luke Bailey or Jason Ryles?

Is it too early for Sam Thaiday, Matt Scott, Luke Lewis, Nate Myles and Simon Mannering to make the jump to rep players?

Is this a break out year for future fantasy stars Michael Gordon, Adam Cuthbertson, William Zillman* and Luke Douglas?

multiple.scoregasms wrote:Let's get some discussion going

Brett Hodgson vs Clinton Schifcofske, do you want the consistency of Schifcofske or the upside from Hodgson?

Mark Gasnier vs Matt Cooper, the flashy attack of Gasnier vs the reliable defense of Cooper?

Do you pay the premium for Kurt Gidley given he averages 11 higher than the next best half? Or do you chase some value?

Which tackle bot 2RF do you want? Paul Gallen, Craig Fitzgibbon, Ben Kennedy

Do you go with future fantasy immortal Corey Parker or the already established Dallas Johnson?

Do you lock in a work horse prop like Shane Webcke, Luke Bailey or Jason Ryles?

Is it too early for Sam Thaiday, Matt Scott, Luke Lewis, Nate Myles and Simon Mannering to make the jump to rep players?

Is this a break out year for future fantasy stars Michael Gordon, Adam Cuthbertson, William Zillman* and Luke Douglas?

multiple.scoregasms wrote:Let's get some discussion going

Brett Hodgson vs Clinton Schifcofske, do you want the consistency of Schifcofske or the upside from Hodgson?

Mark Gasnier vs Matt Cooper, the flashy attack of Gasnier vs the reliable defense of Cooper?

Do you pay the premium for Kurt Gidley given he averages 11 higher than the next best half? Or do you chase some value?

Which tackle bot 2RF do you want? Paul Gallen, Craig Fitzgibbon, Ben Kennedy

Do you go with future fantasy immortal Corey Parker or the already established Dallas Johnson?

Do you lock in a work horse prop like Shane Webcke, Luke Bailey or Jason Ryles?

Is it too early for Sam Thaiday, Matt Scott, Luke Lewis, Nate Myles and Simon Mannering to make the jump to rep players?

Is this a break out year for future fantasy stars Michael Gordon, Adam Cuthbertson, William Zillman* and Luke Douglas?

mattnz wrote:

I dont have  a single one of any of the players in this post.

I feel like from all the comments so far, that my team is really different to anyone elses. It surprises me as I see it as being a pretty standard team, where I havent tried to get too tricky, by going for any PODs, just generally gone for what I see as those that I know become guns and trying to pick value.

multiple.scoregasms wrote:You guys know this is the fantasy thread not the know your shittos thread right?

Welshy wrote:Shall we start posting our teams? Not like it’s a secret we all do it in the usual fantasy thread don’t we

Welshy wrote:Shall we start posting our teams? Not like it’s a secret we all do it in the usual fantasy thread don’t we

multiple.scoregasms wrote:

This is way more competitive than regular fantasy

multiple.scoregasms wrote:This was also the time of 12 interchanges so current fantasy rules may not apply(80 minute hookers and second rowers)

mattnz wrote:

Its funny how everyone is secretive in this, but happy to post in a normal season.

I think it may be the difference between being one of 100k teams and trying to get a competitive advantage as a group vs this where there will be <20 teams and everyone here is your direct competition.

multiple.scoregasms wrote:Let's get some discussion going

Brett Hodgson vs Clinton Schifcofske, do you want the consistency of Schifcofske or the upside from Hodgson?

Mark Gasnier vs Matt Cooper, the flashy attack of Gasnier vs the reliable defense of Cooper?

Do you pay the premium for Kurt Gidley given he averages 11 higher than the next best half? Or do you chase some value?

Which tackle bot 2RF do you want? Paul Gallen, Craig Fitzgibbon, Ben Kennedy

Do you go with future fantasy immortal Corey Parker or the already established Dallas Johnson?

Do you lock in a work horse prop like Shane Webcke, Luke Bailey or Jason Ryles?

Is it too early for Sam Thaiday, Matt Scott, Luke Lewis, Nate Myles and Simon Mannering to make the jump to rep players?

Is this a break out year for future fantasy stars Michael Gordon, Adam Cuthbertson, William Zillman* and Luke Douglas?

Welshy wrote:

Still all done to luck though really I don’t think people posting will make others change too much but then again I could be very wrong

I think I picked more on player name at league level more than fantasy which could backfire for me but it’s only a game

multiple.scoregasms wrote:

It is very close to super coach scoring so will come down to players that score a try each week

mattnz wrote:

Its funny how everyone is secretive in this, but happy to post in a normal season.

I think it may be the difference between being one of 100k teams and trying to get a competitive advantage as a group vs this where there will be <20 teams and everyone here is your direct competition.

Welshy wrote:

For sure so far more luck involved I think and you don’t get all the TBs which usually come with them

I don’t mind discussing players and my thoughts, I agonised over halves the most I think. With no TAs awarded and KM not being a thing I was looking more at running halves went 1 GUN in Thurston who I’m hoping also kicked conversions and perceived value in Cronk. Cronk is my worry with no TAs and no conversion extras but surely scores more than the 4 tries in year previous

I went with Thurston over Lockyer because surely Locky loses some Of those conversion attempts to Parker