NRL Fantasy 2022 Part 12 - The first rule of trade club is, we only trade CTRs

standard-issue wrote:

100% mate.  Schiller's JS dicey and that could be Burton's floor.

Yep, if you just look at Burton's role, you can't complain about him getting 500 km and goal kicking.

He may end up being my Cleary enabler, but otherwise short of disaster won't be trading him.

Ramitinmyhaaas wrote:It would be dumb to trade Coates -> Schiller which gives me the funds to go Burton --> Grant aye???

Yes

Camo123 wrote:

Still would just drop out for Rapana next week when back from suspension???

Possibly, or Valemei.

I'm looking desperately for a cow lol.

Camo123 wrote:

Still would just drop out for Rapana next week when back from suspension???

Reckon Valemei gets dropped.

Trading vailea for anyone under 300k tossing up between
Wishart / w smith / Walter's
Any suggestions on who to go with?

mickspicks wrote:

Reckon Valemei gets dropped.

Kris in the mix too, back from covid.

Fantasyjesus wrote:Trading vailea for anyone under 300k tossing up between
Wishart / w smith /  Walter's  
Any suggestions on who to go with?

Would go Max King ahead of any of them if you don't have him.

mattnz wrote:
Would go Max King ahead of any of them if you don't have him.

Had him to start ( glad one of my cows is going well lmao )

Vailea doesn't suck as much as we think he does. Got his injured knee 20 minutes into the game. Will have significantly impacted his performance.

mattnz wrote:

Kris in the mix too, back from covid.

Its definitely a competitive backline. I had Schiller from the get go but it would be risky to bring him in now, but I like his style and can see him holding a spot.

mickspicks wrote:

Its definitely a competitive backline. I had Schiller from the get go but it would be risky to bring him in now, but I like his style and can see him holding a spot.

Really really tempted just to take the punt.

Schiller might not even survive the 24 hr cull, let alone have longer term security.

24 Hour update

@storm
Garlick, Nikorima, Pezet, Howarth, Warbrick

@SSFCRABBITOHS
Knight, Kennar, Mamouzelos, Tass, Hawkins

mattnz wrote:
Either 80 on an EDG, or 60-70 including 20-30 on the EDG and rest in the MID

I don't think he will play 80 on the edge. I think it's Luki's edge, just that he isn't the 80 minute motor like Nanai, more the 60 minute Kikau-esque impact player. Luki will either get his 60 straight up, or coming on from the bench for more impact against tired defenders. I still think Gilbert is a good bet (I put him in the second his name hit the updated team list), but I would be expecting either 20 minutes on the edge and another 30 in the middle or just a straight 45-50 mins from the bench.

Have enough results in the Cleary poll to indicate some trends.

About 80% of Haas owners are happy to wait on Cleary, not get him immediately.
Approx 50/50 for non-Haas owners on whether they will get Cleary asap.
Lots more Haas owners than non-Haas owners in the poll, so roughly 1/3rd planning to get Cleary in straight away overall.

Pookus McFly wrote:

I don't think he will play 80 on the edge. I think it's Luki's edge, just that he isn't the 80 minute motor like Nanai, more the 60 minute Kikau-esque impact player. Luki will either get his 60 straight up, or coming on from the bench for more impact against tired defenders. I still think Gilbert is a good bet (I put him in the second his name hit the updated team list), but I would be expecting either 20 minutes on the edge and another 30 in the middle or just a straight 45-50 mins from the bench.

You should listen to the interview with Payten. https://www.cowboys.com.au/news/2022/03/15/payten-hes-forced-his-way-into-the-starting-side/

Looks set to play a big role as a starter. Coach really rates him.

Great having Gilbert knowing that his high work rate in big minutes is what is keeping him there, should see it every week.

Milchcow wrote:

if he gets a consistent 20 minutes for a few weeks (and potentially builds on that throughout the season), he might be valuable as a Haas enabler

Hame Sele should be back soon in a couple of weeks anyway he makes our best 17.

Honey Badger wrote:

Seems like Arrow played extra minutes. Would he normally go off for 5 mins then come back on?

He is very important to us I can’t see him playing less than 60mins tbh.

Coming to the realisation I'm not trading Bird to Nanai or Billy to Will Smith. Just have the post Rd 1 transfer DTs

wolfking wrote:Sounding like Croker won't be back anytime soon.  Has a bulging disc now.

The Schiller punt still looking tempting.....

Croker should retire