NRL Fantasy 2022 Part 36 - Battle of Hastings...Jazz vs Cheese

GarethEllisismyDad wrote:Thoughts on this trade

Randall and Schneider out

Hastings and tevaga in

I personally think you shouldn't be trading either but it would be a points upgrade. Schneider will continue to pump out 40s and plays rd 13. Doubt Randall will get hooked every week and should bounce back points wise. But if youve got no other potential trade outs then back yourself and go for it. Im lucky (glass half full) to have Curran and Nanai as tradeouts

Mr Snrub wrote:

The Panthers are going to beat them by 30 points instead of 40?

That wouldn't be very honest.

GarethEllisismyDad wrote:18-21 are Walters, ilias, Thompson, rushton,

Interchange is max king, Hastings, josh king, starling

Schneider price let’s me get tevaga and Hastings otherwise it’s trading out Thompson and getting koula, (which I don’t mind)

But I see this as the only week timing wise to get Hastings and tevaga, otherwise I’ll have missed them and won’t go back

If it was me Josh King would be gone for Tevaga for sure! Not sure if you caught the news, but Tui K is back for Storm.

Doubt that Cheese is the one losing minutes, most likely King gets much less minutes going forward.

precursor wrote:
I personally think you shouldn't be trading either but it would be a points upgrade. Schneider will continue to pump out 40s and plays rd 13. Doubt Randall will get hooked every week and should bounce back points wise. But if youve got no other potential trade outs then back yourself and go for it. Im lucky (glass half full) to have Curran and Nanai as tradeouts

Interestingly I see Nanai in the same way you see Scheider, averaging aroung 40 and plays R13. He's a hold for me.

mattnz wrote:Anyone on the fence about trading out Nanai, he is up against iPap this week.

don't they both play on their team's right side

Why is players playing Rnd 13 important in the overall scheme of things? If they dont play 13 they play 17 right?

precursor wrote:

don't they both play on their team's right side

Weird, they were mentioning it on NRL360.

mattnz wrote:

If it was me Josh King would be gone for Tevaga for sure! Not sure if you caught the news, but Tui K is back for Storm.

Doubt that Cheese is the one losing minutes, most likely King gets much less minutes going forward.

Josh is on notice for sure

sajjos wrote:Why is players playing Rnd 13 important in the overall scheme of things? If they dont play 13 they play 17 right?

Longer to wait to cash out a cow / midranger and longer period they could get injured /dropped within. Can be ok if they are a full gun, or borderline gun.

These are some players I’m not trading out yet, I’m not sure their work is done

Jones
Randall
Nanai
Schneider

Wasn’t everyone mad keen on ditching Scrichton last week?

I appreciate the comments but like someone said earlier I’m a trade whore and I want jazz and Hastings,

Trade made,

Worried randall makes 70+ tackles this week but I’ll cop that

the_great_wobbler wrote:

Interestingly I see Nanai in the same way you see Scheider, averaging aroung 40 and plays R13. He's a hold for me.

Nanai could easily have peaked and can score < 20. Schneider is much more consistent, with a low of 34. Feel much more comfortable playing him in my 17 than I did with Nanai.

Nanai's BE is 15 points higher this week.

Ramitinmyhaaas wrote:Promising stat here for Hastings

Halfback touches average per game:

Hastings - 96
Hunt - 69 ( )
DCE - 65
Hynes - 60
Cleary - 59

Spells inefficient.

Nanai hasn't scored 40 since round 4, if you're selling anyone it's him. He's not the worst to hold if you need to, but if you're getting a guy like Hastings or Jazz, he's the one you'd sell.

Aardvark wrote:

Schneider to Hastings seems slightly sideways…Hastings has potential but I’d try to be trading out someone on a downward arc otherwise there’s an opportunity cost. Not sure either of these two are in your final 17 so you want to maximise usefulness

Look at this guy, all serious when I'm not around... sprung !

the_great_wobbler wrote:

Interestingly I see Nanai in the same way you see Scheider, averaging aroung 40 and plays R13. He's a hold for me.

I'd be surprised if that happens but if he does then I'm happy to be proven wrong. I won't be deathriding him at all. Schneider hasn't been reliant on tries to save his score.

Revraiser wrote:

Look at this guy, all serious when I'm not around... sprung !

I need something to work with!!!!

Back to normal service tomorrow

Edit : The mood today has been sombre to say the least

Snatchpato wrote:
Jeez our teams are similar LB. You have stronger edges, I have Haas. You have Clark, I have SWalker. Those are the only discernable notable differences. Explains why we're both travelling so poorly so far (though inside top 20k here for 2nd week straight, woo!)

Fwiw I double traded and got Tevaga and Koula this week

Haha as have I, think I gained 1000 ranks or so. Can’t exactly confirm that without going on the site.

Koula is an interesting one. Surely doesn’t have long left in the team? Could be quite the enabler

Bethany_B wrote:Nanai hasn't scored 40 since round 4, if you're selling anyone it's him. He's not the worst to hold if you need to, but if you're getting a guy like Hastings or Jazz, he's the one you'd sell.

I have such a soft spot for him, keep thinking he’s gonna pull it together and get a huge score soon, I’m holding him,

I do understand the logic of trading him

filthridden wrote:

Even if he "only" scores 45 for the next two weeks, he's still making you almost $100k in that time which is a very quick, big cash boost.
Even if you don't think he's worth the cash currently/he's not a keeper, you're not going to get a better opportunity to make such quick cash with an upside with the potential to be very big indeed... in a year people are struggling to make money.

Surprised more aren't having more than a sniff at that.

Is this correct? If it is, I may consider him even more again.