HomeIf you had to leave one out between: Garner, Katoa, E Butcher, who gets the cut?
NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
mrbrownstone- Posts : 5342
Reputation : 2496
Join date : 2019-09-13
- Post n°421
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by mrbrownstone Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:07 am
Milchcow
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25408
Reputation : 17833
Join date : 2015-07-31
- Post n°422
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Milchcow Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:08 am
What are people from Egan Butcher. His stats are good, but they are mostly on the edge
This is his only start at edge
https://www.footystatistics.com/matches.php?m=1112430&year=2021
This game I think he played edge after Keighran went down and (I think) Sitili went to CTR
https://www.footystatistics.com/matches.php?m=1112370&year=2021
Which are probably good enough stats to go for. But I have a few concerns and wondering if I can spend that money on someone better
BCT05- Posts : 5521
Reputation : 2467
Join date : 2020-03-19
- Post n°423
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by BCT05 Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:08 am
mrbrownstone wrote:If you had to leave one out between: Garner, Katoa, E Butcher, who gets the cut?
Has to be Garner for me
Goodnight Kiwi- Posts : 1118
Reputation : 1019
Join date : 2018-01-09
Location : Christchurch
- Post n°424
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Goodnight Kiwi Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:09 am
Bethany_B wrote:
Hughes doesn't really kick across the field much, and I can see them going both ways, as both Coates and Warbrick are good in the air.
Warbrick seems like he'll have much better base than Coates, he's just a bigger body and gets through a lot of work.
Coates 194cm, 108kg
Warbrick 193cm, 105kg
wolfking- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 34157
Reputation : 14195
Join date : 2016-04-26
Age : 40
Location : Brisbane
- Post n°425
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by wolfking Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:10 am
my tv broke wrote:
Carty Party Time Of Death Thursday night 55th minute when hooked for Jack Murchie.
Named to start in round 2... in NSW Cup
Yeah, I've gone cold hey. I hate Doorey though but think he hangs around longer than Carty.
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25408
Reputation : 17833
Join date : 2015-07-31
- Post n°426
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Milchcow Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:10 am
mrbrownstone wrote:If you had to leave one out between: Garner, Katoa, E Butcher, who gets the cut?
Making a similar choice. Pretty sure I want Katoa
So tossing up Butcher or Garner + cash, currently leaning Butcher
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25408
Reputation : 17833
Join date : 2015-07-31
- Post n°427
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Milchcow Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:12 am
wolfking wrote:
Yeah, I've gone cold hey. I hate Doorey though but think he hangs around longer than Carty.
We've been making jokes about the Door being boring, but if he just sits around in a 60-80 minute role he is going to make cash. He won't do it super quickly, or fill you with excitment whilst he does it, but his scores will be solid enough.
I am a sucker for a party though, so currently still on Carty
Guest- Guest
- Post n°428
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Guest Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:14 am
my tv broke wrote:
Carty Party Time Of Death Thursday night 55th minute when hooked for Jack Murchie.
Named to start in round 2... in NSW Cup
55 mins is 50 more than I need for a Party
ynot- Posts : 757
Reputation : 1797
Join date : 2021-03-23
- Post n°429
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by ynot Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:19 am
Milchcow wrote:
What are people from Egan Butcher. His stats are good, but they are mostly on the edge
This is his only start at edge
https://www.footystatistics.com/matches.php?m=1112430&year=2021
This game I think he played edge after Keighran went down and (I think) Sitili went to CTR
https://www.footystatistics.com/matches.php?m=1112370&year=2021
Which are probably good enough stats to go for. But I have a few concerns and wondering if I can spend that money on someone better
His NSW Cup numbers at starting Edge aren't amazing, but he only has 8 starts there and none in 2022. Closer to a 0.55 PPM / 45 ish average.
I think that's the baseline if he's playing 80. Naufahu Whyte on the bench is primarily an Edge too, so there might be some positional switches.
I'd expect a 50 average as a median outcome?
Loomer- Fanatic
- Posts : 10738
Reputation : 4331
Join date : 2016-01-29
- Post n°430
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Loomer Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:19 am
Milchcow wrote:
Making a similar choice. Pretty sure I want Katoa
So tossing up Butcher or Garner + cash, currently leaning Butcher
I've downgraded Nat Butch to Sutton to make Katoa into Teddy. No thought of losing Egan and still think Katoa needs try to score decent
Bethany_B- Posts : 7393
Reputation : 3278
Join date : 2018-02-05
- Post n°431
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Bethany_B Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:23 am
Goodnight Kiwi wrote:
Coates 194cm, 108kg
Warbrick 193cm, 105kg
I didn't think Coates was that huge Jesus Christ, thought he was like 90-95kg
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28424
Reputation : 21079
Join date : 2016-01-08
- Post n°432
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by my tv broke Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:23 am
Coates just runs funny
Shady2K- Posts : 5867
Reputation : 3221
Join date : 2020-03-12
- Post n°433
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Shady2K Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:24 am
All these Wilton comments make me nervous. Concern with the four forward bench
Tino also looks like a good POD if he gets good minutes… which the bench points to
Tino also looks like a good POD if he gets good minutes… which the bench points to
mrbrownstone- Posts : 5342
Reputation : 2496
Join date : 2019-09-13
- Post n°434
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by mrbrownstone Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:25 am
At the moment I'm going back and forth on Turbo + Miller or Teddy + CNK. Thoughts?
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28424
Reputation : 21079
Join date : 2016-01-08
- Post n°435
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by my tv broke Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:26 am
Which side of the field will Tass play on? Whoever suggested him a few pages back, not a bad shout tbh
Ramitinmyhaaas- Posts : 2936
Reputation : 1695
Join date : 2021-01-21
- Post n°436
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Ramitinmyhaaas Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:27 am
Shady2K wrote:All these Wilton comments make me nervous. Concern with the four forward bench
Tino also looks like a good POD if he gets good minutes… which the bench points to
I was just about to say... today I've ended up getting rid of both Egan butch and Wilton due to the fact with Egan I'd have 3 roosters and concered with their bye and Wilton axing due to the comments today and a few people going cold on him.
My alternative I came up with before was getting Uto and Tino for them... looks nice. Tino's prop stats from round 20-25 last year look fantastic!
Bethany_B- Posts : 7393
Reputation : 3278
Join date : 2018-02-05
- Post n°437
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Bethany_B Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:28 am
my tv broke wrote:Which side of the field will Tass play on? Whoever suggested him a few pages back, not a bad shout tbh
Tass is nailed on for the left side which is the money side, only problem is that Trell loves to cut him out for AJ so if you own him, you'll be screaming at your TV for Trell to stop cutting him out, based on my experience owning Gagai in SC in 2021
rhinoceroo- Fanatic
- Posts : 14020
Reputation : 9265
Join date : 2015-09-30
- Post n°438
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by rhinoceroo Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:29 am
my tv broke wrote:Which side of the field will Tass play on? Whoever suggested him a few pages back, not a bad shout tbh
It was me. Would you take him over Staggs? What are you expecting from Staggs this year, Broncoa-wise.
Ramitinmyhaaas- Posts : 2936
Reputation : 1695
Join date : 2021-01-21
- Post n°439
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by Ramitinmyhaaas Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:29 am
Anyone thinking about running Nat Butcher? DPP, solid stats from 2nd row?
rhinoceroo- Fanatic
- Posts : 14020
Reputation : 9265
Join date : 2015-09-30
- Post n°440
Re: NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 6 - We're getting the Carty Party back together
by rhinoceroo Wed Mar 01, 2023 11:32 am
Roosters second row with the blond/brown hair calling us in with what looks like a value fantasy price? It couldn't be, could it?