NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 15 - Cheese and Garlick Naan

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

Yes

Only $49k above his starting and looked threatening outside Hughes. Think he'll only improve and will put up some big scores

Could maintain low 50 keeper territory where you never trade him out because he's good enough and you have other issues to put out

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

He was my 22nd man Rd 1, 15k short of starting with him. I thought the 39 vs. Eels in an armwrestle match was pretty solid and was priced around 32 at the time. Only priced around 36 currently, so I would say yes get on still. If I didn't last week, I would this week.

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

it's a yes from me

If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

Thank you. You good thing you.

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

playing him he's in hot form & his confidence would be high

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

At 497k?

YES

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

You can confidently play him.

Mulvy wrote:

Brown stone has Mulvy on block confirmed.

Hahahaha that's what I get for trying to jump back into the thread without catching up on the last 20 pages

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

If he isnt making your starting 17, there is something wrong with your team balance. Should average around the 50 mark.

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

cost 497k hopefully on average around 45-48, still plenty of cash to make, think he is pretty safe 80 min edge given bellyaches history, he can bust a tackle and has good speed through the line.

tldr - yes.

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

Playing him

mrbrownstone wrote:

Hahahaha that's what I get for trying to jump back into the thread without catching up on the last 20 pages

To summarise, I was pointing out the merits of SJ getting all of the KMs and all of the GK whilst simultaneously trying to talk myself and others out of it.

White Lightning wrote:

playing him he's in hot form & his confidence would be high

Mulvy wrote:

You can confidently play him.

mattnz wrote:

If he isnt making your starting 17, there is something wrong with your team balance. Should average around the 50 mark.

Cheers guys. @mattnz, you know my team structure is rather questionable lol.

I have no idea who to leave out, perhaps Loiero

Doueihi or Dontehi

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

I started with him with view to go in 17 if named to start but was at restaurant and didn't see late mail Rd 2. I'm surprised this is a question. He had big wraps from Gus before Rd 1 and you've seen what happens when he starts. Don't most people have dumpster fire from 16-21 that he's a no brainer?

Mulvy wrote:

To summarise, I was pointing out the merits of SJ getting all of the KMs and all of the GK whilst simultaneously trying to talk myself and others out of it.

That's about where I'm at with it too. The base is super tempting, no one else is kicking at all, but also it's SJ.

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:If bringing in Preston this week are you playing him straight away or stashing away?

Fwiw I'm looping him and IKatoa (who knows if he goes huge against the Knights)

Favour my other edges to at least get a safe 40 before Preston. But obviously if IKatoa only gets like a 30 then Preston is straight into the 17

L-Jimmy wrote:If you didn't have E.Katoa would you bring him in?

Yes, you. I'm talking to you. Would you trade him in?

Cheese to EKotoa my only trade atm. If Doueihi out though I'm a half or hooker down

Mulvy wrote:

To summarise, I was pointing out the merits of SJ getting all of the KMs and all of the GK whilst simultaneously trying to talk myself and others out of it.

yeah I'm happy to let other people take the punt on SJ