2017 NRL.com Fantasy Thread part 20

White Lightning wrote:

The Dragons will do the mauling & thrash the Warriors. I don't think the Warriors have won an away game v the Dragons for years.

Warriors for the spoon!

Bren wrote:Didn't see the game but sounds like Dugan was concussed but didn't go off? Not the only player this week either.

I was at the game and near where it happened. He got knocked out cold, for at least 10 seconds laying there lifeless for much longer.

When he finally got up he staggered a bit, trainer poured water on his face then he just shook it off like trying to wake up

Put it this way, it the rule was brought in to 'protect' players, this was a prime example to use it.

Mighty Fishes wrote:

SI wrote:Fifita down to 2 TB's and Dugan down to 5 after updates.  Not sure if discussed already, but deadset, Prozone must have changed their definition of a TB.

No issues if they have, as they have been quite liberal the last few years, but some notice would have been nice before picking certain players.  For example, picking Fifita and Dugan!

Matt Gillett 'missed' a tackle on Thursday because Vulu ran near him Gillett put an arm out (he was behind Vulu) realised he wasn't going to get him so put his arm down and chased after him someone else made the tackle and Gillett carried on to the 10m line and that was a missed tackle / tackle break even though there was no contact and Gillett was a good metre away from him.

I feel some contact should at least be made for it to be a tackle break not just running past someone clean

Agreed, that scenario if anything is more a line break.  

With the TB definition, it seems at the moment that if you bounce out of a tackle and continue on, but are then tackled by the same tackler again then it is not a TB.  I tend to agree with this, but pretty sure it is not how it has been the last couple of years.  

Normally in season's past, if a player dropped off a tackle but then came back and completed the tackle then it would still be counted as a missed tackle and then a tackle, and hence a TB to the ball carrier.

Boozecluez wrote:

I was at the game and near where it happened. He got knocked out cold, for at least 10 seconds laying there lifeless for much longer.

When he finally got up he staggered a bit, trainer poured water on his face then he just shook it off like trying to wake up

Put it this way, it the rule was brought in to 'protect' players, this was a prime example to use it.

What minute was that in Booze? Thanks.

Edit - Nevermind. FF it through and found it. How the fuck did he not go off for a HIA?!

@Rev

Bet you by 9 points. The difference between Sironen and TRD lol

I think this will be how gallen scores all this year...

Bren wrote:

What minute was that in Booze? Thanks.

Edit - Nevermind. FF it through and found it. How the fuck did he not go off for a HIA?!

Because hes not a forward needing to come off for a free interchange

Ross96p wrote:I think this will be how gallen scores all this year...

Yep. Good 50 point player to have over byes mind you, but doubtful he gets anyone a few 70's like I was hoping for.

745, not too bad seeing I ran Moga, Kelly, Suli and Siro in 17. Picked up 2500 ranks to now be 2160. Heading in the right direction at least.

And I thought Elgey was my biggest problem in the halves. Might downgrade Moses to a cheapie before he ends up at Elgeys price.

Any cheapies worth looking at?

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:And I thought Elgey was my biggest problem in the halves. Might downgrade Moses to a cheapie before he ends up at Elgeys price.

Any cheapies worth looking at?

Do you have Ponga? Could see more game time with all these injuries at the Cowboys that keep popping up. Might get a few additional games during the origin period if he isn't in the side already at that time.

hmmm I would like to keep siro as he has more cash to make, but this crap score has stunted his potential for a while. Will most likely trade him, would you say whitehead should score about 20pts more than siro next weeK?

If he scores a 50 and siro 30, then whitehead drops another 10k and siro picks up 1-2k......yeah definitely will make the trade if whitehead named in 2RF again.


So Siro and MCK after those scores pretty much done as cows? They could both be slow burns for another 50k, but doubt its worth it.

Bren wrote:

Do you have Ponga? Could see more game time with all these injuries at the Cowboys that keep popping up. Might get a few additional games during the origin period if he isn't in the side already at that time.

Don't have any DPPs to get Ponga unfortunately.

Mighty Fishes wrote:Not much needed to say about my week I lost to Honeysett in a H2H

I might as well quit now

I'm 3-0 in the mods league. Don't be upset.

Honeysett wrote:

I'm 3-0 in the mods league. Don't be upset.

and I'm 0-3 in the mods league against you scrubs

thoughts on aubs vs whitehead

manlybeaver wrote:thoughts on aubs vs whitehead

Both? Aubs this week, Whitehead next week?

manlybeaver wrote:thoughts on aubs vs whitehead

Yah I'm fed up already of looking at all these names in my centres. Hate making so many trades there so sooner can have an Aubusson instead of Cotric Suli Idris Kelly the better

Will persist with that sack of garbage Moses due to severe lack of options around his price or below

F*#@ me dead lads that was a belter of a round!!!

So many gumbies ...grrr... Managed 739 somehow. Sitting about 2700th.

Got a bit of work to do on my team though..especially the backs