2017 NRL.com Fantasy thread part 21

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:So is KBrom > AFB a worthwhile trade. 100k cheaper and back this week.

Probably a wasted trade even with the cash banked, did you get Musgrove in? If you did that's 2 mid rangers you will at some point need to upgrade/downgrade

Alright can someone describe what is a good trade to make??

I thought making money was what we're trying to do early

Showbags wrote:Anyone know much the titans situation? Just wanting to know how long cornish will get a run. Thinking of cashing out Elgey, any cash I can bank this round helps fuel weekly mid to gun upgrades over the next 5 rounds.

Would love to know more as well tbh, he looked quite an exciting player and fantasy cow from the bits i saw

Archer wrote:
Would love to know more as well tbh, he looked quite an exciting player and fantasy cow from the bits i saw

yeah, got to be better than elgey surely? I am also thinking of something stupid, Field in at 128k for an extra 10k over a 138k player.

Cornish is so small & tiny every time he gets smashed he gets injured. I would steer clear.

Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:Alright can someone describe what is a good trade to make??

I thought making money was what we're trying to do early

You are 100% correct. A good trade is one that makes you money in the longterm for the most part. (This doesn't include bringing in guns and/or swapping out injured players.)

Now in terms of a good trade for K. Bromwich to A. Fonua-Blake, you need to be making money long term. So a simple way to work this out would be.

How much does K. Bromwich have left to make? How much does A. Fonua-Blake have to make? Then compare the difference to how much a trade is worth. As to bring in Blake and then cash him out/upgrade him will cost an extra trade than to cash out/upgrade K. Bromwich.
(Now I dont have access to my PC right this second so it is rough estimates.)

K. Bromwich could make $25k - $50k in the next two weeks roughly. Most people calulate a trade to be worth around $50k - $100k even though they have no monetary value. Essentiall you want A. Fonua-Blake to make roughly $75k - $150k depending to how you value things. You also can take into account the spare cash you get this round and have to float around as a variable that is worth taking into consideration.

Overall, I actually don't mind the trade. However you would have to crunch the numbers to see if it is worth it to you.

Stick with this rabble or dump Moses

Smith, McCullough
JWH, FKaufusi, Musgrove, Perrett
DeBelin, Surgess, ET, SMat, Sironen, Yates
Moses, Lamb, Elgey, Jacks
Moga, Idris, Cotric, Kelly
CWalker, RTS, Hayne, Abbey, Suli

Moses - Ponga via CWalker + $197,000 1 trade


Moses - Ponga via CWalker
Hayne - Whitehead via SMat into CTR Cotric into WFB

Moses - Field
Sironen - Mannering

any of dem ideas?

I dislike them all Welshy. Whitehead could lose more, Hayne you kept for a reason, Ponga vcould be out of the team soon, Field may get a run later this year but you could be killing off a position and without having a strong second HLF option.

Random wrote:I dislike them all Welshy. Whitehead could lose more, Hayne you kept for a reason, Ponga vcould be out of the team soon, Field may get a run later this year but you could be killing off a position and without having a strong second HLF option.

Have CWalker but moving him weakens my WFB again and Hayne would be gone...

garrrrgghhhhh

Sironen to Simpkins

Suli to Slater

Done and locked in

Think I will go Moses - Fogarty for his DPP

The KBrom > AFB trade will also include Moses > SJ/Norman leaves me enough to go Sironen > Whitehead next week I think

Mighty Fishes wrote:Sironen to Simpkins

Suli to Slater

Done and locked in

I just don't trust Simpkins. Bloke gets injured/concussed easily it seems.

You've got shed loads of cash stored up don't you Welshy?  Any reason all your thoughts are of downgrading Moses (not upgrading), is it just because you've already earmarked that cash for use on guys like Whitehead & JBrom?

Archer wrote:You've got shed loads of cash stored up don't you Welshy?  Any reason all your thoughts are of downgrading Moses (not upgrading), is it just because you've already earmarked that cash for use on guys like Whitehead & JBrom?

Got CWalker in last week didn't I mate so the cash stocks plummeted

Moses will bleed cash with a +60 BE and has looked pretty clueless in all seriousness, few decent forced drop pus but those ain't getting me my fantasy points

Getting rid generates the cash needed to turn Siro - Whitehead and JWH - JBrom

Welshy wrote:
Got CWalker in last week didn't I mate so the cash stocks plummeted

Moses will bleed cash with a +60 BE and has looked pretty clueless in all seriousness, few decent forced drop pus but those ain't getting me my fantasy points

Getting rid generates the cash needed to turn Siro - Whitehead and JWH - JBrom

I hear you (and i think the CWalker move was very well played) but i guess what I'm considering is whether or not you're better off doing another upgrade this week. I mean would getting an extra week or two out of a gun (say scores 50 or 60) be a better return, rather than copping another week of low scorers. Whilst Whitehead could bottom out next week, would he start to rise more than whoever you would be trading out or could you potentially take an extra week to find cash?

Archer wrote:
I hear you (and i think the CWalker move was very well played) but i guess what I'm considering is whether or not you're better off doing another upgrade this week. I mean would getting an extra week or two out of a gun (say scores 50 or 60) be a better return, rather than copping another week of low scorers. Whilst Whitehead could bottom out next week, would he start to rise more than whoever you would be trading out or could you potentially take an extra week to find cash?

Worried about Norman and his hammy, otherwise I would grab him but I would need to find $127,000 to action that trade? Any ideas?

hmm, with all the guns bottoming out shortly, is it maybe worth going from Pritchard to McCullough instead of McInnes and pocketing the 50k?

surmo13 wrote:hmm, with all the guns bottoming out shortly, is it maybe worth going from Pritchard to McCullough instead of McInnes and pocketing the 50k?

I reckon go McInnes. Broncos are struggling to score so I can see Nikorima making a return asap

Spectre wrote:

I reckon go McInnes. Broncos are struggling to score so I can see Nikorima making a return asap

Isn't KNiko already back just not being picked?