Rate My Team 2018

danaconda86 wrote:Or maybe:

HOK: Smith
FRF: J. Brom / Lodge
2RF: JTurbo / N. Brown / Merrin
HLF: Thurston / Croker
CTR: Takairangi / Hiku
WFB: Ponga / Tedesco / Katoa

Int:
C. Murray / Cartwright / L. Latu / L. Leilua

Emerg:
Kikau / Mckendry / Kennar / Havili

Need a better HLF to partner JT

Any thoughts out of 10?

HOK - C.Smith
FRF - J.Bromwich, R.James
2RF - A.Twal, C.Murray, T.Harris
HLF - C.Cronk, B.Croft
CTR - J.Ramien, J.Croker
WFB - J.Hayne, P.Hiku, K.Ponga

INT - B.Green(HLF),
C.Thompson(WFB)
T.Milne(CTR)
M.Lodge(FRF)
EMG - Z.Lomax
L.Leilua
L.Croker
V.Kikau
$31K left in bank

24moz71 wrote:Any thoughts out of 10?

HOK - C.Smith
FRF - J.Bromwich, R.James
2RF - A.Twal, C.Murray, T.Harris
HLF - C.Cronk, B.Croft
CTR - J.Ramien, J.Croker
WFB - J.Hayne, P.Hiku, K.Ponga

INT - B.Green(HLF),
        C.Thompson(WFB)
        T.Milne(CTR)
        M.Lodge(FRF)
EMG - Z.Lomax
           L.Leilua
           L.Croker
           V.Kikau
$31K left in bank

Green doesn't have any real value.
I think there are better options than Hayne, Milne, Ramian. I would have a look through some of the other teams around and the main thread for some ideas.

5/10. You have a decent base to start the team, but just need to mix up some selections.

[quote="Mighty Fishes"]Any advice on my team would be appreciate guys.

Smith
Latu, Lodge
Harris, Merrin, RFM
Croft, Townsend
Taka, Hunt
Katoa, Dufty, Ponga

Lichaa
Cook
NAS
J-Reynolds

Cartwright
Welch
Kennar
Nicholls
[/quote]
Good looking team. Like the bench depth.

I'd worry a bit about JRey behind that Tigers pack, and in front of that uncertain backline. And isn't HHunt is under a bit of an injury cloud? Maybe consider swapping out JRey and HHunt for a roughie like Doueihi and LMitchell/KNiko or Mbye - ie someone who gives you growth options and DPP

Hey guys, starting out on my SuperCoach journey. What is the best thread for NRL SuperCoach info and teams etc?

Ice wrote:Hey guys, starting out on my SuperCoach journey. What is the best thread for NRL SuperCoach info and teams etc?

Either read the Fantasy thread, and apply the wisdom to SC. Most of it is fairly transferable.
We do have an SC thread if you have questions, but it gets little traffic.

Otherwise check out NRLSupercoachtalk, or one of a bunch of Facebook groups.

So what game is everyone playing if not NRL SuperCoach?

Ice wrote:So what game is everyone playing if not NRL SuperCoach?

I dislike Rupert so much that SC isn't an option for me.

1st time at this
Smith
Brom Lodge
J Turbo Whitehead
Merrin
JT
Milf. Milf gone for Croft
Mitchell Linnet. Linnet gone for Aubusson
Hiku Isaako
Holmes. Holmes gone for Ponga

Kikau
Takarangi Takarangi gone for Milne
watson
Cartwright
Leilua. Leilua gone for brown
Nicholls
L Crocker
Katoa

DBayDad wrote:1st time at this
Smith
Brom Lodge
J Turbo Whitehead
Merrin
JT
Milf
Mitchell Linnet
Hiku Isaako
Holmes

Kikau
Takarangi
watson
Cartwright
Leilua
Nicholls
L Crocker
Katoa

- Takarangi isnt worth taking at his price and off the bench.
- There may be better cheap options than Leilua.
- I personally don't like Milf in Fantasy.
- Linnet is injured and isn't the best Fantasy scorer.
- Better FB options than Holmes.
- PLayers to consider. Ponga, Aubs, Croft, Havili.

Hi, please rate my team. Thanks...

How much money ITB?
I can sort of see what you are doing , maybe.
Strong 4 reserves.

Think you're taking a chance with those FRF and WFBs. Suppose that's what's makes the bench strong.
You haven't got reserve cover for center. Consider bringing in DPP Kennar for Clocker?

Hi please rate my teams guys. Cheers

Smith
Lodge Arrow
J Turbo Brown RFM
Croft Carthwright
Hiku Inglis
Ponga Tedesco Katoa

Api K, TPG, Kikau, Rochow

Isaako, Godinet, Nicholls, Kennar

Finch wrote:Hi, please rate my team. Thanks...

As mentioned, the backline looks quite thin and I am not sold on TPJ making that much more than he is priced at tbh. Otherwise the alternative guns are interesting.

Bonanza15 wrote:Hi please rate my teams guys. Cheers

Smith
Lodge Arrow
J Turbo Brown RFM
Croft Carthwright
Hiku Inglis
Ponga Tedesco Katoa

Api K, TPG, Kikau, Rochow

Isaako, Godinet, Nicholls, Kennar

Looks solid. Not sure Korisau has much value, but he is a different pick at least.