Home35k
2018 NRL.com Fantasy thread part 48
Poll
Who are the underdogs for Game 1 of SOO ?
- [ 34 ]
[41%]
- [ 48 ]
- [59%]
Total Votes: 82
Poll closed
Poll closed
danseels1985- Posts : 3592
Reputation : 1367
Join date : 2017-02-21
Welshy- Moderator
- Posts : 27249
Reputation : 10988
Join date : 2015-09-16
Age : 37
Location : Wales
Now it's tough, both punts but could provide solid scores in the interim and generate some cash for R17 upgradesdanseels1985 wrote:35k
could look at
Su'a - Graham
Gos - Guth
Guest- Guest
Eels Nathan Brown trained with squad Today after recovering from ankle injury, final call to be made at Captain's run Friday as to if he plays this weekend
https://twitter.com/WackosWhispers/status/1001764387512700928?s=19
https://twitter.com/WackosWhispers/status/1001764387512700928?s=19
Guest- Guest
Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:Best to cash out to 212k players or will Doughy and TMM suffice?
Having that same thought.
For me buying TMM is really just for his points this week as won't be needed for cover and probably won't get cashed out either.
A 212k DPP WFB/CTR red dot player (Fonua is 18th man) is probably more useful long term (Or Wright if you can guarantee he disappears)
Thinking 68k extra in the bank (By not going TMM) means that is 68k less Martin or Su'a needs to earn in the future (to turn into a keeper) when you want to pull that trigger
Also might mean you can save a trade on a downgrade too to find those funds
So using the example Su'a tops out at 600k, his value is now 668k.. Don't need much in the bank to make him a Cleary
Not sure how it effects your team but I am coming around to going a maximum cash out to save a further trade.
Last edited by Boozecluez on Wed May 30, 2018 8:37 pm; edited 2 times in total
danseels1985- Posts : 3592
Reputation : 1367
Join date : 2017-02-21
Hmm I'm a bit intrigued but Graham hasn't shown much this year and BE is 42 plus Guth won't make much cash the way my boys are playing whereas Sua still has cash to make. My way of thinking was Lane has almost peaked so he is the obvious choice to go after this week while Gos could make money again if he keeps a spot in the team. You've made me think though lol
Welshy- Moderator
- Posts : 27249
Reputation : 10988
Join date : 2015-09-16
Age : 37
Location : Wales
Apologies in advance for this long winder
Was looking at my trade ins, team for R13 and team for R14 and had a thought of whether it's worth field a decent 13 this week if my team next round would be too mid range punt heavy (JFriend + WGraham with JFH also on the bench)
R13 team after trades
Cook - Surgess
Capewell - JFriend
Isaako - WGraham
Friend
Fifita, Surgess
TLolo, Murray, Barnett
ARey, TMM
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga
WGraham
Cogger
(smith, kikau, martin, JFH, Mbye, Ted, RFM, Arrow)
So I'm now considering only bringing in only one of Friend/Graham and getting in Doui instead as it generates an extra $207,000 minimum, then lobbing Barnett for Harris this week which would allow me to get in both McInnes and SJ next round for Murray and Cogger)
theory behind that is not leaving so much money on the bench (Graham, JFH, RFM) and getting gun Top 17 keepers in quicker
so R14 team would look like
Smith
Fifita, Arrow
TLolo, Harris, Surgess
ARey, SJ
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga, Tedesco, Mbye
Friend/RFM
McInnes
Martin
Kikau
JFH, TMM, Doui, Friend/RFM
Does that makes sense?
sacrificing Barnetts score this week to allow me to get in 3 R17 and top 17 keepers in?
Was looking at my trade ins, team for R13 and team for R14 and had a thought of whether it's worth field a decent 13 this week if my team next round would be too mid range punt heavy (JFriend + WGraham with JFH also on the bench)
R13 team after trades
Cook - Surgess
Capewell - JFriend
Isaako - WGraham
Friend
Fifita, Surgess
TLolo, Murray, Barnett
ARey, TMM
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga
WGraham
Cogger
(smith, kikau, martin, JFH, Mbye, Ted, RFM, Arrow)
So I'm now considering only bringing in only one of Friend/Graham and getting in Doui instead as it generates an extra $207,000 minimum, then lobbing Barnett for Harris this week which would allow me to get in both McInnes and SJ next round for Murray and Cogger)
theory behind that is not leaving so much money on the bench (Graham, JFH, RFM) and getting gun Top 17 keepers in quicker
so R14 team would look like
Smith
Fifita, Arrow
TLolo, Harris, Surgess
ARey, SJ
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga, Tedesco, Mbye
Friend/RFM
McInnes
Martin
Kikau
JFH, TMM, Doui, Friend/RFM
Does that makes sense?
sacrificing Barnetts score this week to allow me to get in 3 R17 and top 17 keepers in?
TheBadger- Posts : 71
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2018-04-04
Thoughts on this one fellas? My first year fantasy so not to sure how to deal with the bye rounds and 4 trade options. From what I see you wanna try get many guys on the field as possible. My current team;
Cook
Arrow Fifi
Lolo TPJ Harris
Cogger DCE
Inglis Isaako
Teddy Ponga Thompson
McCullough Smith Kikau RFM
JFH Martin Hipgrave Havili
Had fuck all playing R13, so thinking, planned trades;
Isaako -> Fonua
RFM -> Friend
Inglis -> Dugan
JFH -> TMM
Leaving me with 12 trades left, $654k ITB. Reasonable? Or is it a bit overkill? Cheers in advance.
Cook
Arrow Fifi
Lolo TPJ Harris
Cogger DCE
Inglis Isaako
Teddy Ponga Thompson
McCullough Smith Kikau RFM
JFH Martin Hipgrave Havili
Had fuck all playing R13, so thinking, planned trades;
Isaako -> Fonua
RFM -> Friend
Inglis -> Dugan
JFH -> TMM
Leaving me with 12 trades left, $654k ITB. Reasonable? Or is it a bit overkill? Cheers in advance.
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
WT2K wrote:Eels Nathan Brown trained with squad Today after recovering from ankle injury, final call to be made at Captain's run Friday as to if he plays this weekend
https://twitter.com/WackosWhispers/status/1001764387512700928?s=19
If he doesn't play this week I am booting him. Don't care if he is back next week. I have held him since Round 5. 7 FUCKING ROUNDS. STUPID PIECE OF SHIT EELS CANT SORT THEIR INJURY TIMELINES AND SORT SHIT AT ALL. FUCKING USELESS FUCKS CAN'T JUST TELL ME WHEN HE WILL BE BACK. INSTEAD I GET STUCK WITH THE FUCKING LUMP IN MY TEAM FOR 7 WEEKS. FUCKING TAUPAU SCORED 435 FUCKING POINTS WHILE THIS GUY WAS ON THE PINE! FUCK I COULD HAVE EVEN TRADED HIM TO DUGAN WHO GOT INJURED AND STILL CAME BACK BEFORE HIM. FUCKING DUGAN. DUDE WAS SUPPOSE TO BE TOUGH, FUCKING JAI ARROW IS TOUGH. FUCK YOU BROWN! ALSO WHY THE FUCK DO YOU HAVE THE SAME GENERIC ASS NAME AS THE FUCKING NEWCASTLE CAPTAIN. MAKES IT BLOODY DIFFICULT TO FUCKING SEARCH FOR SHIT ABOUT YOU. INSTEAD I GET BOMBARDED WITH... "Well the Knights are shit, Nathan Brown responds." THEY HAVE BEEN SHIT FOR AGES. JUST PUT UP A CONSISTENT FUCKING INJURY REPORT SO I DON'T LOOK STUPID FOR HOLDING HIM FOR SO LONG. SPEAKING OF FUCKING STUPID, I JUST REALISED I COULD HAVE USED CAPSLOCK THIS ENTIRE TIME, INSTEAD OF HOLDING SHIFT. FUCK. THEN I HAVE PEOPLE SAYING. "Don't think about how long you have held him. Think about how long until he returns." THAT WAS 4 FUCKING WEEKS AGO WHEN I THOUGHT HE WAS ONE OR TWO WEEKS OUT. FUCK YOU NATHAN BROWN.
Seriously though, I really like Brown as a player and wish him a speedy recovery, and hope he puts out an 80 points as I must be the only sad fuck with him still in my squad. I also actually like Nathan Brown the Newcastle coach as well, but shit it makes life hard when you try and search one of them up.
mickspicks- Posts : 3488
Reputation : 1076
Join date : 2017-04-23
Location : Phin Fully Up 4 Herbie
Will be interesting to see how Nathan Brown impacts Parra rotations. I assume he goes to lock again obviously, but he was playing 70 mins (3 Out of 5 games). Does Terepo slot in at prop or 2RF? When Mannah comes back, does Alvaro’s minutes decrease? I assume Manu Ma’u stays as an 80min edge forward.
mickspicks- Posts : 3488
Reputation : 1076
Join date : 2017-04-23
Location : Phin Fully Up 4 Herbie
Random wrote:
If he doesn't play this week I am booting him. Don't care if he is back next week. I have held him since Round 5. 7 FUCKING ROUNDS. STUPID PIECE OF SHIT EELS CANT SORT THEIR INJURY TIMELINES AND SORT SHIT AT ALL. FUCKING USELESS FUCKS CAN'T JUST TELL ME WHEN HE WILL BE BACK. INSTEAD I GET STUCK WITH THE FUCKING LUMP IN MY TEAM FOR 7 WEEKS. FUCKING TAUPAU SCORED 435 FUCKING POINTS WHILE THIS GUY WAS ON THE PINE! FUCK I COULD HAVE EVEN TRADED HIM TO DUGAN WHO GOT INJURED AND STILL CAME BACK BEFORE HIM. FUCKING DUGAN. DUDE WAS SUPPOSE TO BE TOUGH, FUCKING JAI ARROW IS TOUGH. FUCK YOU BROWN! ALSO WHY THE FUCK DO YOU HAVE THE SAME GENERIC ASS NAME AS THE FUCKING NEWCASTLE CAPTAIN. MAKES IT BLOODY DIFFICULT TO FUCKING SEARCH FOR SHIT ABOUT YOU. INSTEAD I GET BOMBARDED WITH... "Well the Knights are shit, Nathan Brown responds." THEY HAVE BEEN SHIT FOR AGES. JUST PUT UP A CONSISTENT FUCKING INJURY REPORT SO I DON'T LOOK STUPID FOR HOLDING HIM FOR SO LONG. SPEAKING OF FUCKING STUPID, I JUST REALISED I COULD HAVE USED CAPSLOCK THIS ENTIRE TIME, INSTEAD OF HOLDING SHIFT. FUCK. THEN I HAVE PEOPLE SAYING. "Don't think about how long you have held him. Think about how long until he returns." THAT WAS 4 FUCKING WEEKS AGO WHEN I THOUGHT HE WAS ONE OR TWO WEEKS OUT. FUCK YOU NATHAN BROWN.
Seriously though, I really like Brown as a player and wish him a speedy recovery, and hope he puts out an 80 points as I must be the only sad fuck with him still in my squad. I also actually like Nathan Brown the Newcastle coach as well, but shit it makes life hard when you try and search one of them up.
Liverpool_Bulldog- Fanatic
- Posts : 19477
Reputation : 6801
Join date : 2016-02-14
Location : New Zealand
Welshy wrote:Apologies in advance for this long winder
Was looking at my trade ins, team for R13 and team for R14 and had a thought of whether it's worth field a decent 13 this week if my team next round would be too mid range punt heavy (JFriend + WGraham with JFH also on the bench)
R13 team after trades
Cook - Surgess
Capewell - JFriend
Isaako - WGraham
Friend
Fifita, Surgess
TLolo, Murray, Barnett
ARey, TMM
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga
WGraham
Cogger
(smith, kikau, martin, JFH, Mbye, Ted, RFM, Arrow)
So I'm now considering only bringing in only one of Friend/Graham and getting in Doui instead as it generates an extra $207,000 minimum, then lobbing Barnett for Harris this week which would allow me to get in both McInnes and SJ next round for Murray and Cogger)
theory behind that is not leaving so much money on the bench (Graham, JFH, RFM) and getting gun Top 17 keepers in quicker
so R14 team would look like
Smith
Fifita, Arrow
TLolo, Harris, Surgess
ARey, SJ
Dugan, Fonua
Ponga, Tedesco, Mbye
Friend/RFM
McInnes
Martin
Kikau
JFH, TMM, Doui, Friend/RFM
Does that makes sense?
sacrificing Barnetts score this week to allow me to get in 3 R17 and top 17 keepers in?
Sounds like an interesting strategy. The thought of selling Cook terrifies me but I know it's something you've put some thought into so all good.
Also I've noticed you don't own Taupau!? What's the reason behind that??
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
TheBadger wrote:Thoughts on this one fellas? My first year fantasy so not to sure how to deal with the bye rounds and 4 trade options. From what I see you wanna try get many guys on the field as possible. My current team;
Cook
Arrow Fifi
Lolo TPJ Harris
Cogger DCE
Inglis Isaako
Teddy Ponga Thompson
McCullough Smith Kikau RFM
JFH Martin Hipgrave Havili
Had fuck all playing R13, so thinking, planned trades;
Isaako -> Fonua
RFM -> Friend
Inglis -> Dugan
JFH -> TMM
Leaving me with 12 trades left, $654k ITB. Reasonable? Or is it a bit overkill? Cheers in advance.
I really like it, but don't get hung up on the bye rounds too much. Round 17 is going to lay waste to many. Many will struggle to field 5-6 players that round.
I am not sold on Friend magically returning to form, I would say that trading him in is definitely a risk at this stage until he pumps out a big score. Last week he got a TA and a LBA. He has only gotten a TA one other time this season, and the LBA is his first. Add to that him missing 1 tackle instead of his average of 4 tackles per game. Meant he got a higher score. If he were to hit 60 points this week, you would have more concrete proof and it would only cost you $37k. I would pick another gun. Especially with so much damn money in the bank.
Taupau would be a great option, Matterson as well and it fixes your halves. I actually really like the idea of Matterson for your team and you can move him to the 2RF if you decide to grab Cleary. Hell turn JFH into Taupau as well, sure it eats up your cash but really stacks your side for this bye round and gives you 3 certain keepers in your team and a long term prospect in Fonua. Then you can look at other cheapies next week. (You also don't have many trades so you want to get to your final team soon and TMM/Friend might not fit the picture.
Welshy- Moderator
- Posts : 27249
Reputation : 10988
Join date : 2015-09-16
Age : 37
Location : Wales
I refuse to pay $877,000 (62 avg) for him when he is averaging 56. Boosted by back to back games where he went 24 and 48 points above itLiverpool_Bulldog wrote:
Sounds like an interesting strategy. The thought of selling Cook terrifies me but I know it's something you've put some thought into so all good.
Also I've noticed you don't own Taupau!? What's the reason behind that??
On top of that he has failed to beat his current average 75% of his matches (4 from 12).
Do I want him? Yes.
Do I want him at current price? Yes.
Will I actually pay out for him? No.
filthridden- Moderator
- Posts : 19241
Reputation : 12118
Join date : 2015-09-27
Random wrote:
If he doesn't play this week I am booting him. Don't care if he is back next week. I have held him since Round 5. 7 FUCKING ROUNDS. STUPID PIECE OF SHIT EELS CANT SORT THEIR INJURY TIMELINES AND SORT SHIT AT ALL. FUCKING USELESS FUCKS CAN'T JUST TELL ME WHEN HE WILL BE BACK. INSTEAD I GET STUCK WITH THE FUCKING LUMP IN MY TEAM FOR 7 WEEKS. FUCKING TAUPAU SCORED 435 FUCKING POINTS WHILE THIS GUY WAS ON THE PINE! FUCK I COULD HAVE EVEN TRADED HIM TO DUGAN WHO GOT INJURED AND STILL CAME BACK BEFORE HIM. FUCKING DUGAN. DUDE WAS SUPPOSE TO BE TOUGH, FUCKING JAI ARROW IS TOUGH. FUCK YOU BROWN! ALSO WHY THE FUCK DO YOU HAVE THE SAME GENERIC ASS NAME AS THE FUCKING NEWCASTLE CAPTAIN. MAKES IT BLOODY DIFFICULT TO FUCKING SEARCH FOR SHIT ABOUT YOU. INSTEAD I GET BOMBARDED WITH... "Well the Knights are shit, Nathan Brown responds." THEY HAVE BEEN SHIT FOR AGES. JUST PUT UP A CONSISTENT FUCKING INJURY REPORT SO I DON'T LOOK STUPID FOR HOLDING HIM FOR SO LONG. SPEAKING OF FUCKING STUPID, I JUST REALISED I COULD HAVE USED CAPSLOCK THIS ENTIRE TIME, INSTEAD OF HOLDING SHIFT. FUCK. THEN I HAVE PEOPLE SAYING. "Don't think about how long you have held him. Think about how long until he returns." THAT WAS 4 FUCKING WEEKS AGO WHEN I THOUGHT HE WAS ONE OR TWO WEEKS OUT. FUCK YOU NATHAN BROWN.
Seriously though, I really like Brown as a player and wish him a speedy recovery, and hope he puts out an 80 points as I must be the only sad fuck with him still in my squad. I also actually like Nathan Brown the Newcastle coach as well, but shit it makes life hard when you try and search one of them up.
Post of the year contender!
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
mickspicks wrote:Will be interesting to see how Nathan Brown impacts Parra rotations. I assume he goes to lock again obviously, but he was playing 70 mins (3 Out of 5 games). Does Terepo slot in at prop or 2RF? When Mannah comes back, does Alvaro’s minutes decrease? I assume Manu Ma’u stays as an 80min edge forward.
I don't think Arthur has any problem slotting Moeroa to the bench. I would say Ma'u stays an 80 minute edge forward. I think Alvaro's score will slip a little with Mannah and Brown both in the pack. He will get around that 50 minute mark, but I don't think we will see him making 45+ tackles a game.
I reckon they line up like the following.
D. Alvaro - T. Mannah
M. Ma'u - N. Brown - P. Terepo
W. Smith, T. Moeroa, S. Vave, S. Matagi
Terepo and Moeroa are interchangeable but Moeroa offers more impact off the bench imo.
code delta- Posts : 3321
Reputation : 1766
Join date : 2016-05-05
Welshy wrote:
What's a moron mission?
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
filthridden wrote:
Post of the year contender!
Really hoping I pull a MTM with him.
RandomSil- Moderator
- Posts : 9953
Reputation : 3222
Join date : 2015-01-12
Age : 32
Welshy wrote:I refuse to pay $877,000 (62 avg) for him when he is averaging 56. Boosted by back to back games where he went 24 and 48 points above itLiverpool_Bulldog wrote:
Sounds like an interesting strategy. The thought of selling Cook terrifies me but I know it's something you've put some thought into so all good.
Also I've noticed you don't own Taupau!? What's the reason behind that??
On top of that he has failed to beat his current average 75% of his matches (4 from 12).
Do I want him? Yes.
Do I want him at current price? Yes.
Will I actually pay out for him? No.
This is my reasoning, but then I look at the fact last time he played the Knights he hit 104 points.
Liverpool_Bulldog- Fanatic
- Posts : 19477
Reputation : 6801
Join date : 2016-02-14
Location : New Zealand
Welshy wrote:
I refuse to pay $877,000 (62 avg) for him when he is averaging 56. Boosted by back to back games where he went 24 and 48 points above it
On top of that he has failed to beat his current average 75% of his matches (4 from 12).
Do I want him? Yes.
Do I want him at current price? Yes.
Will I actually pay out for him? No.
Haha I feel the exact same way about that price, it will be out of the calls soon as well.
I could forgo him and pick up Fitzgibbon and NBrown instead, both good options I reckon.
Liverpool_Bulldog- Fanatic
- Posts : 19477
Reputation : 6801
Join date : 2016-02-14
Location : New Zealand
Random wrote:
This is my reasoning, but then I look at the fact last time he played the Knights he hit 104 points.
Lucky he's not playing the Knights then haha