NRL Fantasy 2019 Part 26

Finch wrote:Question for those that are on the fence about CHT, and a question we should all be asking ourselves.


If Keighran wasn't starting in Week 1, and instead CHT was, would you of purchased CHT?

If yes, buy this week.

Seems simple to me?

The key difference is we werent expecting Green to dominate all ball playing to that degree in the first 3 games. Keighran had one half of one game where he got any decent ball in attack. If CHT has the same fate, then he can't score well.

Finch wrote:Question for those that are on the fence about CHT, and a question we should all be asking ourselves.


If Keighran wasn't starting in Week 1, and instead CHT was, would you of purchased CHT?

If yes, buy this week.

Seems simple to me?

The problem is that Keighran won that spot on merit and has lost his spot for no other reason than the Warriors have a shit pack. You can't out-half shitty go-forward and middle-defence. The only change they made is to drop Bunty to the bench and bring LAM into the starting. That's not going to fix Blair and Papali'i (internally raging at SK right now).

TLDR: CHT is just as likely to lose his spot because the Warriors can't analyse their game properly

Welshy wrote:James prop move helps Carty lock down opposite edge to Proctor doesn't it?

Phwoar that looks good on you, orange is your colour mate!

really tempted to ignore rein, but he was so instrumental in last years charge.

Will it be rotating halves now, keighran out, keighran in, for the rest of the year?

mattnz wrote:

Yeah if Xerri kills it, he owns right center for the season, maybe Moylan comes back for The Chad.

Drop a premiership winning half to accommodate a rookie in the centres? Doubtful matw.

mattnz wrote:

The key difference is we werent expecting Green to dominate all ball playing to that degree in the first 3 games. Keighran had one half of one game where he got any decent ball in attack. If CHT has the same fate, then he can't score well.

No but CHT is far more off the cuff and has a far more advanced running game, so I'd expect some TBs/LBs

Archer wrote:
Phwoar that looks good on you, orange is your colour mate!

could of been far worse mate, I'm quite thankful

Another doomsday scenario would be CHT getting injured in his first game

My plan this week is to see the carnage that has happened, take a deep breath and move forward with the trades that will benefit my term long term. One round playing lesser back up players isn't going to win or lose me anything. I want to generate cash and get keepers into my side. With that said. Macca/Arrow are gone for Rein/Ponga. Ponga might bleed some more cash but getting him in this week allows me to see what we get out of the carnage. There's so many options if they flop you've wasted two trades and money getting them in and out of your team.

Think I’ve had too many beers.
I’ve just gone

Burns to rein
Keirghan to carty.

Can’t decide if I’m plugging hole sshort term or do I follow my trades and run with 16 this week

Honeysett wrote:

Drop a premiership winning half to accommodate a rookie in the centres? Doubtful matw.

If anything Feki's spot is under fire

Honeysett wrote:My plan this week is to see the carnage that has happened, take a deep breath and move forward with the trades that will benefit my term long term. One round playing lesser back up players isn't going to win or lose me anything. I want to generate cash and get keepers into my side. With that said. Macca/Arrow are gone for Rein/Ponga. Ponga might bleed some more cash but getting him in this week allows me to see what we get out of the carnage. There's so many options if they flop you've wasted two trades and money getting them in and out of your team.

What are your thoughts on Arrow?

Whats the go if Arrow doesn't score 50+ this week, will everybody trade him out or stick with him.

I'll wait a week on CHT. If he goes well and is set for some decent price rises, I can cash somebody out to him.

If Green still hogs the ball and whatnot then trap avoided.

Welshy wrote:No but CHT is far more off the cuff and has a far more advanced running game, so I'd expect some TBs/LBs

Yup but SJ was an off-the-cuff player too. He had base-stats though

Honeysett wrote:

Drop a premiership winning half to accommodate a rookie in the centres? Doubtful matw.

If anything Feki's spot is under fire [/quote]

This. Why tf would they drop Townsend?

Honeysett wrote:

Drop a premiership winning half to accommodate a rookie in the centres? Doubtful matw.

Chad is a journeyman, who happened to be in a premiership side. Xerri will be a gun center.

churg wrote:Whats the go if Arrow doesn't score 50+ this week, will everybody trade him out or stick with him.

Taupau into my 2RF's and Bateman can come in I guess. He'd have to go sub 45 for me to seriously consider trading him out though. He's had 3 quite varying scores so it's hard for me to get a read on him.

Surely Kearny isn't dull enough to just give CHT the same prove it weeks as Keighrgan, my thoughts are that it was a literal coin flip as beginning of season and Keighran simply hasn't done enough in his opinion.

Problem with Warriors pack isn't going to go away and SJ saved us so many times just dazzling and papering over the cracks, CHT is far more SJ than AK, I think I might take the punt. Something has to go right for me at some point

Finch wrote:Question for those that are on the fence about CHT, and a question we should all be asking ourselves.


If Keighran wasn't starting in Week 1, and instead CHT was, would you of purchased CHT?

If yes, buy this week.

Seems simple to me?

I'm in that camp and doing it