Last year I ignored Cook/Smith and started with Jake Friend, which probably would have worked out just fine if Friend didn't get injured. So I'll be looking for a similar strategy this year
NRL Fantasy 2020 Part 1 - Offseason Edition
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
Last year I ignored Cook/Smith and started with Jake Friend, which probably would have worked out just fine if Friend didn't get injured. So I'll be looking for a similar strategy this year
mattnz- Fanatic
- Posts : 19887
Reputation : 7191
Join date : 2018-03-11
Location : Your pool
Honey Badger wrote:
This is the big one for me. Whether to start with Haas or not. I'm definitely going to aim to start with him. I think if you dont start with him the temptation will be to use the extra cash to pick too many mid-range players
Thats exactly where I am at. If there were enough high end of mid range players that are actually underpriced guns, like D Fifita then you could do it, but ones like Tevaga that would have been a great candidate for that strategy is injured. If Haas and other top guns were higher priced, it would have made the strategy more viable.
mattnz- Fanatic
- Posts : 19887
Reputation : 7191
Join date : 2018-03-11
Location : Your pool
Milchy wrote:
Captain will be whoever the highest scoring player in my side is.
Some of the extra captain points from Haas is taken up by the ownership bump to his price.
I'm, also concerned by Haas not having a single bad round last year. That surely can't continue.
For Haas to rise significantly in price he will have to go on the greatest run of fantasy scores ever seen. Sure it's possible, but I'm not going to bet on it
I think Haas has upside the next few seasons. Look at a guy like Taumalolo, he didnt become a great player until his early 20s which Haas is about to enter now. Front rowers are still developing at his age. At his peak he could be getting 1 PPM playing 80 minutes.
Last edited by mattnz on Thu Jan 16, 2020 9:42 pm; edited 1 time in total
Ben Marlin- Posts : 1003
Reputation : 342
Join date : 2019-05-19
Luke Garnermattnz wrote:
Thats exactly where I am at. If there were enough high end of mid range players that are actually underpriced guns, like D Fifita then you could do it, but ones like Tevaga that would have been a great candidate for that strategy is injured. If Haas and other top guns were higher priced, it would have made the strategy more viable.
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 14022
Reputation : 6176
Join date : 2019-07-24
I’ll be curious to see his price, big question is can he keep finding the tryline? If not he may not make much money at all if he’s priced at mid 40’s, also with Chee Kam and maybe Lawrence on the bench I can’t see him getting 80mins.Ben Marlin wrote:
Luke Garner
Edit. I forgot Luciano as well, I just can’t see Garner getting more than 55-60mins.
Ben Marlin- Posts : 1003
Reputation : 342
Join date : 2019-05-19
Garner is by far the best edge back-rower in the club. He will definitely get 70+ minutes every week no doubt. I expect him to average about 55 and be in the origin discussion.Rabbits21 wrote:
I’ll be curious to see his price, big question is can he keep finding the tryline? If not he may not make much money at all if he’s priced at mid 40’s, also with Chee Kam and maybe Lawrence on the bench I can’t see him getting 80mins.
Edit. I forgot Luciano as well, I just can’t see Garner getting more than 55-60mins.
Lawrence will not make the top 17 (unless there’s injuries)
I think Chee-Kam will come on for about 20 minutes to give Leilua a rest.
mattnz- Fanatic
- Posts : 19887
Reputation : 7191
Join date : 2018-03-11
Location : Your pool
Who is the person you thought was going to be a big winner in 2019, who didnt meet expectations, but you think they will get there this season instead now, while everyone else is gun shy about getting burned by them again.
Possible options could be the likes of Croft, Friend, SST, SJ, Staggs, Moylan, Taylor, James, Stimson, Edwards, Sele, Roberts, Radley or someone else.
Possible options could be the likes of Croft, Friend, SST, SJ, Staggs, Moylan, Taylor, James, Stimson, Edwards, Sele, Roberts, Radley or someone else.
Guest- Guest
Fantasy God himself Corey Parker returning to the 9s
Camo123- Fanatic
- Posts : 13186
Reputation : 9530
Join date : 2019-01-30
mattnz wrote:Who is the person you thought was going to be a big winner in 2019, who didnt meet expectations, but you think they will get there this season instead now, while everyone else is gun shy about getting burned by them again.
Possible options could be the likes of Croft, Friend, SST, SJ, Staggs, Moylan, Taylor, James, Stimson, Edwards, Sele, Roberts, Radley or someone else.
Sele won’t be getting redemption, he’s probably still asleep. But actually he’s unsigned by Panthers and they have better and/or younger forwards and nearly a full top 30 squad
A few of these including SJ, Staggs, Friend had gun averages while people had them after R16 or early rounds in Friend’s case so it shouldn’t deter people from picking them from getting burnt. It’d be more because they will be priced higher now. The first 5 + James, Stimson and Edwards should be good options this year
robelgordo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13119
Reputation : 9659
Join date : 2019-07-08
Location : Sydney
mattnz wrote:
If he was getting 80 minutes at lock again, yes, but not on an edge, need to find value in your starting team.
Bateman only played 3 games at lock and had a higher average starting in the 2nd row.
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 14022
Reputation : 6176
Join date : 2019-07-24
I heard rumours Leilua is struggling at training with Madge’s tough approach, no idea if there is any truth but I heard he’s just not fit at all.Ben Marlin wrote:
Garner is by far the best edge back-rower in the club. He will definitely get 70+ minutes every week no doubt. I expect him to average about 55 and be in the origin discussion.
Lawrence will not make the top 17 (unless there’s injuries)
I think Chee-Kam will come on for about 20 minutes to give Leilua a rest.
Wow Luciano and Garner starting and Lawrence out of the 17, big call!
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 14022
Reputation : 6176
Join date : 2019-07-24
I don’t know if I can go with Edwards again after last season, most people sold him by round 5 or so and I holded out more and more keeping the faith til round 8 or 9 and it just kept getting worse!Camo123 wrote:
Sele won’t be getting redemption, he’s probably still asleep. But actually he’s unsigned by Panthers and they have better and/or younger forwards and nearly a full top 30 squad
A few of these including SJ, Staggs, Friend had gun averages while people had them after R16 or early rounds in Friend’s case so it shouldn’t deter people from picking them from getting burnt. It’d be more because they will be priced higher now. The first 5 + James, Stimson and Edwards should be good options this year
He averaged 42ish if I recall so he will cost probs a little over 600k, I just dunno if there is enough value there.
If Verrills isn’t on the bench for Rorters or gets injured in trials then I would consider Friend.
I would want Friend playing at least 70mins and it worries me at about the 60-61min mark Robbo will take him off and play Verrills. If I got Friend I’d want him playing 80mins and averaging about 60 not playing 60-61mins and averaging around 47-48ish
StormTrooper96- Posts : 9974
Reputation : 3353
Join date : 2018-02-26
Age : 28
Doeuihi been told he is free to leave the club and look elsewhere
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 14022
Reputation : 6176
Join date : 2019-07-24
The media have twisted it a bit but that’s the usual, he’s been told we are happy for him to stay but if he can get a guaranteed 1 or 6 jersey starting elsewhere then we don’t mind if he takes it and are happy for him to take the opportunity.StormTrooper96 wrote:Doeuihi been told he is free to leave the club and look elsewhere
What Souths won’t do though is pay part of his deal the next two years like the Tigers want us too. If they want him they’ll have to pay his full salary from here on out.
I understand Douiehi is 450k with us this season and 550k for 2021.
Personally I hope we don’t lose him, but if he goes I could wish him nothing but the best.
Ben Marlin- Posts : 1003
Reputation : 342
Join date : 2019-05-19
Luciano may not be the fittest but he can certainly play long minutes when needed and thrives doing so.Rabbits21 wrote:
I heard rumours Leilua is struggling at training with Madge’s tough approach, no idea if there is any truth but I heard he’s just not fit at all.
Wow Luciano and Garner starting and Lawrence out of the 17, big call!
In his 9 starting appearances over the last 2 season he has averaged 76 minutes and 54.78 fantasy points - not bad from somebody who isn't fit.
9 starting appearances over 2 seasons is not much but to be fair he is stuck behind two rep-level backrowers.
Madge's tough approach can only be a good thing and should help Leilua be able to maintain his current record starting in the back row over an entire season (I don't think he will average 76 minutes over the season but I do think he'll definitely be starting).
There's no way on earth Garner will not be starting on the left edge in round 1 (unless an injury occurs)
Lawrence does not have the same impact off the bench as Chee-Kam (scored match-winning tries on 2 separate occasions this year) so I'm pretty sure Lawrence won't be in the Tigers best 17.
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
Rabbits21 wrote:
it worries me at about the 60-61min mark Robbo will take him off and play Verrills.
Roosters starting hookers have averaged 70 minutes over the past 2 years - but I guess they probably want to improve on recent performances so good chance their coach might shake things up with how the side runs.
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 25395
Reputation : 17817
Join date : 2015-07-31
Rabbits21 wrote:
I heard rumours Leilua is struggling at training with Madge’s tough approach, no idea if there is any truth but I heard he’s just not fit at all.
Wow Luciano and Garner starting and Lawrence out of the 17, big call!
Leilua spent a week in hospital over Xmas due to an infection. Other than that he is getting the usual puff pieces about being fit and loving the new club
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 14022
Reputation : 6176
Join date : 2019-07-24
So you reckon Luciano plays about 55mins?Ben Marlin wrote:
Luciano may not be the fittest but he can certainly play long minutes when needed and thrives doing so.
In his 9 starting appearances over the last 2 season he has averaged 76 minutes and 54.78 fantasy points - not bad from somebody who isn't fit.
9 starting appearances over 2 seasons is not much but to be fair he is stuck behind two rep-level backrowers.
Madge's tough approach can only be a good thing and should help Leilua be able to maintain his current record starting in the back row over an entire season (I don't think he will average 76 minutes over the season but I do think he'll definitely be starting).
There's no way on earth Garner will not be starting on the left edge in round 1 (unless an injury occurs)
Lawrence does not have the same impact off the bench as Chee-Kam (scored match-winning tries on 2 separate occasions this year) so I'm pretty sure Lawrence won't be in the Tigers best 17.
Garner to play 80?
Rapture_NRL- Posts : 3293
Reputation : 1193
Join date : 2017-02-28
Location : Earth
Milchy wrote:
Last year I ignored Cook/Smith and started with Jake Friend, which probably would have worked out just fine if Friend didn't get injured. So I'll be looking for a similar strategy this year
I did the same and it would have been great if he managed to start fit. I think I'll start with him again at his price. Bit of a risk but rather take it early. Only concern would be Verils.
I agree with your points about avoiding Haas. I think Fifita provides better value and probably won't score too far behind him in the opening rounds.
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 28416
Reputation : 21074
Join date : 2016-01-08
I also started without Cook/Smith. I had intended to do the same this year, as well as Haas, but finding Haas had to ignore.
When you realise his bad games are low 50s
Milchy wrote:I'm, also concerned by Haas not having a single bad round last year. That surely can't continue.
When you realise his bad games are low 50s