SuperCoach 2020

WT Winfield wrote:

I went for Klemmer last week despite the high BE and pretty happy with him partnering Haas. BE is 54 this week, so may have bottomed out. I was just gonna roll with Haas and Carrigan for awhile until the suspension.

JTB might have peaked, but Warriors are running out of players, so not sure he's an urgent trade. BE is his average this week at ~50.

JSaifiti probably hold. Rudolf close to peaking too, but vs. Titans this week, maybe not urgent either.

I jumped off Luciano last week because of some natural Tigers scepticism and his high BE/injury concerns. I think if you can turn him into a top tier gun, it's probably worth doing.

Maybe cashout one of JTB/Rudolph or Luai if you have him and upgrade Luciano to a gun SR or FR via Saifiti?

Klemmer looks good but maybe Vaughan is another

Clack Bocks wrote:

Klemmer looks good but maybe Vaughan is another

Yeah I had Vaughan in my mind last week with JGraham gone, wanted to see him get a minutes bump to ~60 and I'd be all over him. Low 50s I'm not sure he's worth the little extra cash saved.

WT Winfield wrote:

Yeah I had Vaughan in my mind last week with JGraham gone, wanted to see him get a minutes bump to ~60 and I'd be all over him. Low 50s I'm not sure he's worth the little extra cash saved.

Yeah I need to spend three more weeks liberating cash. Don’t have Cleary and need a good front rower. Ctw sorted start the moment and same with full back and second row.

WOW, thanks for all the choices.
I need someone good because atm I'm running Rudolf, Geyer and Molo with Hass. I have Carrigan I can move, and get a 2rf. I'll only have 534 000, so can't afford Klemmer.
Maybe I should just lose on Molo, and trade elsewhere.
I moved Yeo to 2RF last week, and want him back in CTW asap, so maybe Williame out for a nuffie, then next week, I'll have enough for Klemmer.
Is it too early to be thinking nuffie?

BSmith could be a nice pick-up. Been stuck playing 45 mins. Scored a couple of tries to keep his average decent, but seems like he'd do well with 60-80 mins.

Not sure he'll play 80.. Maybe Jacks comes on for him and Cam back to HK, but even 60ish mins should be pretty good.

I'm not as confident in the cheaper FR/SR options.

Mofo maybe the pick of them for consistency. Aloiai while Twal's gone for a short time. Vaughan if anticipating his minutes to increase.

SRs like Lane, Hess, Fitzgibbon need tries I think. Arrow's dropped some cash. Elliot might be stuffed by Thompson's arrival, Dogs a bit of a lottery.

Don't mind the punt on BSmith with the role change over those guys. Plenty of trades to burn when Munster comes back.

Wait, did I dream that previous post?

WT Winfield wrote:Wait, did I dream that previous post?

LOL, no I deleted because I changed my mind and I thought nobody was around to answer. Opinion seems to be that BSmith won't play 80 mins, and this change is only for the Roosters game.
My gut said to do it, but I guess I'm trying to be wise.

Ah okay. Yeah if only for this game, then maybe BSmith isn't worth it. So annoying, guy's a gun and can't get the minutes

I'm not so confident to make strong recommendations on the others. Your decisions past seasons have been way better than mine too, so probably best to not listen to me too much anyway

WT Winfield wrote:Ah okay. Yeah if only for this game, then maybe BSmith isn't worth it. So annoying, guy's a gun and can't get the minutes

I'm not so confident to make strong recommendations on the others. Your decisions past seasons have been way better than mine too, so probably best to not listen to me too much anyway

I love your advice and ideas! It's like getting a tip on the horses, I don't have to pay attention, but it is great to know.
I'll watch and maybe get him next week?

Thanks

I've lost confidence in my advice lately. Talked a friend out of BMoz in favour of Haas a few weeks ago.. Hasn't worked out well.. Same friend I talked out of Flanno for Munster last week, and mentioned Munster to Cleary this week might be good.. meanwhile Flanno's killing it again

I don't mind making bad decisions for my team, but hurts more when someone else follows my advice and doesn't work out.. and with your ranking I feel even more apprehensive haha.

Hopefully works out whatever you do, killing it so far

WT Winfield wrote:Thanks

I've lost confidence in my advice lately. Talked a friend out of BMoz in favour of Haas a few weeks ago.. Hasn't worked out well.. Same friend I talked out of Flanno for Munster last week, and mentioned Munster to Cleary this week might be good.. meanwhile Flanno's killing it again

I don't mind making bad decisions for my team, but hurts more when someone else follows my advice and doesn't work out.. and with your ranking I feel even more apprehensive haha.

Hopefully works out whatever you do, killing it so far

My ranking is a sheer accident, and is scaring me, lol.
I think any advice comes with good intentions, and the decision is mine. I'm sure your friend feels the same. You think of things I haven't because you have more knowledge.
I don't like using both my trades on Thurs, because I don't know what is likely to happen in the rest of the round, so at least I still have a trade if someone vital is out

Thank goodness I kept Sivo .... and played him!

I had a look at his price, similar to lomax etc but I think my lack of a good front rower is more important. Then again it’s about points in the 17 not so much where from I guess

Ozymandias wrote:Thank goodness I kept Sivo .... and played him!

Well done!
I'm hoping for SJ to do the same today!

Where was this last week, Coates

WT2K wrote:Where was this last week, Coates

Yes! I panic traded when Hammer was a scratching, and I could have simply played Coates!
Oh well, I guess we made money

Thinking I should get Teddy this week with Ponga's BE so high. Prefer to trade out the guys that get me Ponga though with any two of Guler/Fui/EKatoa to Fermor/Ponga.

For Teddy it has to be Drinkwater to nuffie 5/8 and Papenhuyzen to Teddy. Pick up Fermor next week if he's still around, but probably miss the potential gains of Field if he miracles some decent scores in Moses' absence.

Was kinda hoping to keep Paps for the Titans in 2 weeks and then trade him to Teddy before his Warriors, Titans etc. run.. but Teddy's next 2 with Cows and Raiders are looking busted and as he showed vs. Storm, he doesn't need weak opposition anyway

My rank keeps going back. Don't think that's the aim of the game

All good mate, those small ranking drops will turn into big gains here soon I reckon. Our teams are almost the same and I've managed to sneak up the last 2 weeks.

I just need to add Ponga and drop GWill to 18th man and team feels complete minus injuries. Maybe Nofo in for Best at some point, or back to Latrell for cheap if he picks up his game.

Klemmer, Murray, SJ and Lomax for me.
Mofo, Leilua, Ponga and Mann for you.

Not much left to do. I upgraded Leilua to Klemmer a couple of weeks ago. I don't mind what I've seen of Leilua, but feel he's short of being top tier for fantasy. SC is a wild game though, jags a try and you're laughing.

Mann scoring tries all the time when under an injury cloud recently keeps pissing me off, but Lomax is jagging them too, so can't complain

Up to 93rd overall now. Going to bring in big Ken and Cleary this round