by easytiger Mon Jan 31, 2022 6:44 am
mattnz wrote:Last year was an unusual one. Very few cows that kicked on, we had guns becoming super-guns.
Milchcow wrote:There were many cows that kicked on last year
Top 20 money makers as below - almost all of them available at $300k or under.
There were some guns that also made money, including guys like Cleary.
But to say few cows kicked on is just wrong. Name | Min | Max | Diff |
Tom Trbojevic | 477000 | 1098000 | 621000 |
Josh Curran | 246000 | 683000 | 437000 |
Jake Averillo | 291000 | 714000 | 423000 |
Nicho Hynes | 327000 | 744000 | 417000 |
Reuben Garrick | 367000 | 780000 | 413000 |
Corey Harawira-Naera | 310000 | 721000 | 411000 |
Braydon Trindall | 228000 | 630000 | 402000 |
Reece Walsh | 228000 | 629000 | 401000 |
Jayden Brailey | 410000 | 796000 | 386000 |
Stefano Utoikamanu | 246000 | 626000 | 380000 |
Tyson Gamble | 246000 | 615000 | 369000 |
Josh Schuster | 274000 | 613000 | 339000 |
Haumole Olakau'atu | 292000 | 629000 | 337000 |
Isaiah Papali'i | 529000 | 855000 | 326000 |
Sam Walker | 228000 | 551000 | 323000 |
Connor Watson | 323000 | 643000 | 320000 |
mattnz wrote:
So of the list you provided, which was the top money makers for the season, there was only 1 highly owned player that consistently performed throughout the season.
The rest were unexpected PODs or had a glimpse of form at the start or end of season. None were consistent performers like a Haas, Grant, Nikora etc in their breakout cow seasons.
Really different from most seasons. Case closed!
A few observations on this:
1/ Milch, your list of the top 20 money makers, only has 16 people. I hope you're not a Maths teacher
2/ Matt claimed "Very few cows that kicked on"
Milch claimed "There were many cows that kicked on last year"
Of the top 16 money makers listed, 12 (i.e. 75%) were within $100k of basement price (i.e. cows) - I think that's a pretty clear case that there were a significant number of cows that kicked on.
3/ Matt's point seemed to revolve around ownership, so I'm guessing what you meant was that there weren't any obvious cheap cows available for Round 1 that made lots of money.
However, in your list of "consistent performers like Haas, Grant, Nikora" - only Nikora was a round 1 cow.
As someone said earlier, the best cows seldom are round one starters, it's why the game is primarily a trading game. You can't win with a starting squad, but if you get it wrong by going too POD, you can set yourself far enough back that it's a real handicap to your trading game.
Last edited by easytiger on Mon Jan 31, 2022 7:42 am; edited 1 time in total