mattnz wrote:
I was looking at that last night.
His stats on the edge are great. Averages 40 tackles and 94 running meters as base. Doesn't need to be in the middle to rack up the tackle count. Compare him to Crichton at 33 tackles last year and iPap at 32.
When playing in the middle his base is similar over 67 minutes, but he tends to have less attacking stats.
I would consider owning him on the edge where he averaged 9 points higher than at lock last year.
He seemed to suffer a bit his last few games, at the end of a high work rate 1st full season. Can see him having a great run to start the year with the Warriors having the easiest run for the first 5 games. Could easily be a cut priced iPap or Crichton, hitting some 80s and 90s if he gets over the try line.
I'm fairly keen on Curran as well (possibly as an alternative for TPJ).
TPJ looks to be 5-6 points under valued and should be around that 60 average on the edge.
Curran is 7k more expensive (pretty much the same price), and could be anything from priced appropriately, to maybe a 60-65 point player? (I.e. 0-10 points of value) - his game looks well suited to fantasy.
I think the real benefit with Curran is that I can see him going on a run of big scores for a month, before settling back to regular 40-60s.
TPJ's judiciary record is well documented, last year restricting him to 18 of a possible 24 regular season games.
Curran so far seems to pick up the odd unlucky minor injury, that isolation event and maybe a 1 week suspension? (from memory). Meaning he managed 14 of a possible 19 games (since he started in round 6).
TPJ seems to be a lot more disciplined these days, but his history means an accidental crusher etc could see him miss multiple weeks.
It's a bit of a conundrum to my mind, fortunately I'm unlikely to be able to afford either.