NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 11 - The case of the mistrusted team lists

Chucky wrote:I finally managed to catch up on all of todays posts.
I think I need a HIA.

Syzy wrote:

Still shows try saves 0, so the error has not been fixed.

Camo123 wrote:I decided to do a Rabbits and ask NRL Feedback about the CNK try save on Ponga.

This is their response:

Spoiler:

Mulvy wrote:

 Sorry if I contributed to the headache mate

Shady2K wrote:

Yeah imo the party should really get more attendees...

Pre-season you may have been laughed at for having Carty in your 17 but now it looks very stable for the next few rounds at a minimum. Downgrading someone like Cheese or Garner to him pockets you some change to fix another position and get similar scoring in the process (plus the cash gen)

His second row starts (full games) historical ave is 48. For argument's sake you could get the same score from a Bird, or a Mahoney, or a Walsh (some names being thrown around as trade ins) but all these guys cost 200-300k more

Personally I don't think Matto is a real risk either to his spot. He could be on the edge when he returns, sure, but his best footy has been as a bench impact middle. In 2022 in this role, he made his Origin debut, and Eels made the GF. It's hard to see Eels move away from that - especially when both Carty/Doorey are serviceable, and the obvious fact that their bench lacks punch. Anyone who saw the R1 game can see that when Paulo/RCG came off that their middle completely fell apart as their bench is inexperienced - Matto fixes that

That's why I'm getting Carty anyway. Should've started with him probably but wasn't sure he'd get the 80 - now that we see that he did - then I'm on board

Mulvy wrote:

Sounds like they are asking to be inundated every time people don't get the stat they want, so that it's added before lockout. Seems a short-sighted response. I reckon, "soz, we stuffed up, will try harder next time" would have been better.

standard-issue wrote:

Agreed, but sometimes double Cow in can also equal double Guns in:

Carty and Mbye in for me this week

Aardvark wrote:

But does it have the role you expected for it this season?

Milchcow wrote:

People complain about all stats all the time, but I've found try saves to be the must contentious.

Sometimes seemingly obvious ones get denied, and sometimes people get one for random shit.

Outsourcing stat checks into hoping customers complain us a terrible business model however.
Just encourages fantasy players to mass spam whinges about players they own, and makes it harder to pick up obvious errors.
they are supposed to review every game anyway. How did this get missed twice. It wasn't a subtle play

bigdog777 wrote:Is tommy Gilbert a hold?

Could trade:
Gilbert -> Cartwright
AKF -> Ilias

If I don’t trade him I can’t make either trade. Feel like both trades are going to make enough to make it worth it?

syn13 wrote:before people get starting on the expected reactions i feel like this part of the link should be noted:



ie. this is a stats provider screw-up, not a fanhub screw-up, and i agree with their stance about errors found post-lockout not being adjusted, messing with points & prices after people have been moving players around would cause problems.

bigdog777 wrote:Is tommy Gilbert a hold?

Could trade:
Gilbert -> Cartwright
AKF -> Ilias

If I don’t trade him I can’t make either trade. Feel like both trades are going to make enough to make it worth it?

Blain wrote:

I'm questioning Gilbert also. He was pretty bad last week, but still pulled 45 in 50 minutes with a tone of negative points. I actually think Gilbert is a hold for now, but if you're chasing cash it's not a terrible idea. I can't see him being any better than a fringe keeper/early $600k guy. AKF to Ilias is a nice upgrade, but not sure if Ilias is anything more than a quick cash maker..

For everyone getting Jackson Ford, just keep in mind Curran was injured most pre season, and is building fitness slowly.. Hence him coming off the bench currently.

People surely aren't getting Mbye? Come on..

I really liked what I saw in Hammer last weekend, super involved, looks to be their main point of attack. Was in my side until Saturday night, so thinking of upgrading AFK to him as my only trade this week.

Mulvy wrote:

If Ilias is a quick cash maker, that's exactly what we want, so great. Not convinced he makes enough though, maybe? Thanks for the advice re: Ford, is there a world where he holds his spot?? I'm going to watch the game again I think. New coach, so who knows?

Revraiser wrote:

You have been making alot of sense of late, everything good at home?

syn13 wrote:

yeh, isn't it a wonder what happens when a person isn't having to constantly battle against being surrounded by factors amplifying the effects of life-long anxiety disorders and clinical depression?