NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 36 - At the going down of the sun

my tv broke wrote:Carty Party confirmed starting.

Must have got the late mail from the same source as the one that had Garner replacing Hosking

So maybe I just revert to original plan of no trades.

That kinda makes thing tougher. Was all set to trade him to Manu.

Mulvy wrote:

 likes the Rabbitohs because he has a green Xmas tshirt with a Reindeer on it. Green =  Rabbitohs. He calls it his Reindeer Rabbithohs Shirt. He tipped them last night and is still on top of the ladder.

Batman seems like a super cool dude - you've got to love the way kids minds work

wolfking wrote:

That kinda makes thing tougher.  Was all set to trade him to Manu.

ET's Carty -> Manu confirmed
Ain't nothing derailing me from jumping on this Manu train

my tv broke wrote:Carty Party confirmed starting.

Must have got the late mail from the same source as the one that had Garner replacing Hosking

So maybe I just revert to original plan of no trades.

Yeah, I think this is me too. I do really need to save some trades and I guess this is an invitation to do so.

Not writing Manu off for next week, but with that BE and the question mark over his role and how long that other guy's in reserve grade for, I don't think it's a bad thing to sit on it for a week.

So do we reckon Carty plays 80?

What's his bloody name? Walker. Sam Walker.

Dunster out

easytiger wrote:

ET's Carty -> Manu confirmed
Ain't nothing derailing me from jumping on this Manu train

I guess after last year I have to do the same.

I've moved Carty on for BSmith. Expecting Matto to move to Carty's EDG at some point, probably not first interchange for Hopgood though. Thinking 50 odd mins for Carty again.

Might do Couch to Crossland since I'm not too keen on playing Warbrick or IKatoa 17th man.

WT Winfield wrote:Dunster OUT

Simo CTR, Russel WG

Well this buggers my plans next week to immediately ditch Host

Guess Sele is the only option unless I back Feldt to get his patented 33 average

Unless Turuva is injured there isn’t any option under 300k

Teeth Eater wrote:

Yeah, I think this is me too. I do really need to save some trades and I guess this is an invitation to do so.

Not writing Manu off for next week, but with that BE and the question mark over his role and how long that other guy's in reserve grade for, I don't think it's a bad thing to sit on it for a week.

So do we reckon Carty plays 80?

What's his bloody name? Walker. Sam Walker.

Someone mentioned it earlier today (i think), trading just makes you feel like you're active, doing something in the game. New shiny toy that everyone else seems to be grabbing and you want to get on board.

Who knows with Carty, probably gets subbed off, but may as well stick with him another week and find out.

Don't doubt Manu is a good buy and I want to grab him too. Maybe its a Storm edge that should make way with their byes coming. Maybe I can just wait a week to decide..? Its not like my team is doing any good anyway, but if I keep max trading I'll be properly cooked in a few weeks regardless.

Are simo centre and Russel the same side? Paired with carty?

Broncos left side might run through that like a hot knife through butter

I'm keeping Carty but I need to ditch Doorey for someone cheaper. Slim pickings this week.

I'm off to overthink the trade for 45 minutes and then not be able to make it because I was in the shower.

Camo123 wrote:

Well this buggers my plans next week to immediately ditch Host

Guess Sele is the only option unless I back Feldt to get his patented 33 average

Unless Turuva is injured there isn’t any option under 300k

Yeah early thoughts are Host to Sele too. Pretty much a straight swap? If not maybe a tiny profit

Sele should be negative BE and if he’s getting more minutes then coach thinks he’s capable?

WT Winfield wrote:I've moved Carty on for BSmith. Expecting Matto to move to Carty's EDG at some point, probably not first interchange for Hopgood though. Thinking 50 odd mins for Carty again.

Might do Couch to Crossland since I'm not too keen on playing Warbrick or IKatoa 17th man.

Don't forget one interchange that wasn't used last week will be needed for Hands.

my tv broke wrote:

Someone mentioned it earlier today (i think), trading just makes you feel like you're active, doing something in the game. New shiny toy that everyone else seems to be grabbing and you want to get on board.

Who knows with Carty, probably gets subbed off, but may as well stick with him another week and find out.

Don't doubt Manu is a good buy and I want to grab him too. Maybe its a Storm edge that should make way with their byes coming. Maybe I can just wait a week to decide..? Its not like my team is doing any good anyway, but if I keep max trading I'll be properly cooked in a few weeks regardless.

Yep, I really need some trades saved.

Other factor for me is I can afford Carty to Manu with 2K to spare. If Carty drops a few dollars and/or Manu actually betters his BE (which to be fair, if I thought that was probable I'd pull the trigger) the window on the straight swap closes. So do I just do it this week? Is the question.

I'm sticking strong with the Carty Party. Hope to be giffing it up in a couple of hours

Would you play Carty over any of EKatoa, Loiero, Boyd, Preston?

Higher average than both Boyd and Loiero, but reckon there's a decent chance Carty doesn't play 80.

FaringdonSwirl wrote:Would you play Carty over any of EKatoa, Loiero, Boyd, Preston?

Higher average than both Boyd and Loiero, but reckon there's a decent chance Carty doesn't play 80.

I wouldn't play him over any of those guys.

Partying one more week with Carty. One of my two storm edges will make way for Manu.

Knew this would happen.

Need to stick strong to my trades. Sorry Carty I really am

The Carty party lives on for another week.
With him starting I am happy to hold through this week and address him next week. BE is manageable.

Here's hoping he doesn't go Host mode