Random wrote:
Ia actually really like your breakdown of how to decide who to pick.
Although I am going to nitpick a few things. I really don't understand the Pauli Pauli love, he averaged 30 minutes a game and only managed an average of 18 points. I don't see his minutes increasing dramatically, with Snowden and K. Sims both playing big minutes. (Korbin was averaging 47 minutes last season.) as well as having Stockwell and Paea likely to be on the bench as well. I don't see how Pauli Pauli can make a push for more than 30 minutes, and I don't see his PPM improving either. Making him not a worthy pick.
I think you undervalue Maloney a little just purely because he will be playing without Pearce he averaged 53 points without Pearce (Lowest score 38 points, Highest score 78 points.) But yeah Peats is incredibly hard to pass up.
I'm more on the Pauli bandwagon because of his price. He showed some promise with the eels that given a consistent role and playing time I can see him upping his PPM. Has a fair amount of promise and with his price so low it is hard to pass up, or to pay the extra 100k to Tapine when I think they will see similar scores.
Fair call on Maloney. But when he was without Pearce I imagine Hastings was the other half. As well as Hasting did last year he was still the 2nd option half in those combos and a lot of plays were run through Maloney. Townsend is no slouch at Cronulla. He shared the duties pretty evenly for the most part with SJ and has a solid kicking game to the point where I wouldn't expect Maloney to suddenly get more km's or anything